The War Against the Jews at UC San Diego

David Horowitz was one of the founders of the New Left in the 1960s and an editor of its largest magazine, Ramparts. He is the author, with Peter Collier, of three best selling dynastic biographies: The Rockefellers: An American Dynasty (1976); The Kennedys: An American Dream (1984); and The Fords: An American Epic (1987). Looking back in anger at their days in the New Left, he and Collier wrote Destructive Generation (1989), a chronicle of their second thoughts about the 60s that has been compared to Whittaker Chambers’ Witness and other classic works documenting a break from totalitarianism. Horowitz examined this subject more closely in Radical Son (1996), a memoir tracing his odyssey from “red-diaper baby” to conservative activist that George Gilder described as “the first great autobiography of his generation.” He is author of the newly published book The Great Betrayal (Regnery 2014), which is a chronicle of the Democrats treachery in the war on terror before 9/11 to the death of Osama bin Laden.


[Editor’s note: This speech was delivered at the University of California, San Diego on May 10, 2010 and has been edited for publication.]

The last time I visited this campus was 40 years ago when I came to have lunch with Professor Herbert Marcuse, a malicious Marxist who made a reputation for himself and became a hero to the left by advancing the proposition that if you can claim to speak on behalf of the oppressed you have the right and the obligation to silence, and, if necessary, to obliterate people who disagree with you. This, of course, is the creed of every run-of-the-mill dictator on earth, and it is the creed of the progressive left today.

It is appropriate — and not coincidental of course — that I arrive here during “Israel Apartheid Week” or, as I prefer to call it, “Hitler Youth Week.”  I use that reference because — as should be evident — what is going on here is part of a globally organized movement centered in the Arab Muslim Middle East to finish the job that Hitler started.  Unlike the Nazis, who hid their “final solution” from ordinary Germans and the world at large, the Muslim radicals shout it from the rooftops, put it in their organizational charters and get applauded for doing so by millions of Muslims who want to see it happen.  And the left does its job, as during the Cold War years, of conducting auxiliary campaigns to help the genocide along.

Along with Israel Apartheid Week, these leftists will commemorate what the genocide-minded call the “Nakba,” which is Arabic for “catastrophe” and is the name they have given to the creation of the only Jewish state in existence. The protests are genocidal intentions in themselves, seeking the obliteration of a people’s homeland; and they are supported by this university which prides itself on its diversity and respect for others – apparently excepting Jews. The “Israel Apartheid Wall,” which is the centerpiece of this genocidal week at UC San Diego, was created with $8,500 in student funds. Another $32,000 in student funds went to the sponsoring organization, the Muslim Students Association, for the hate speakers it brought in and other activities this spring. The hate week itself is supported by several university departments, including Ethnic Studies, Visual Arts and Literature, and by one of the colleges of the university, as it happens Thurgood Marshall College, named for a civil rights activist.

It is also fitting that one of the speakers should be Angela Davis, an academic icon and a lifelong Communist who devoted herself to furthering the agendas of the most oppressive, blood-soaked regime in recorded history; and received for her services a Lenin Prize from the East German police state, the most wretched and ruthless of all the Soviet satellite regimes; who bought an arsenal of weapons for a young Black Panther, who attempted to take a judge and his courtroom hostage, blew off the head of the judge and got himself killed in the process.

Today Angela Davis comes as the leader of a 20-year campaign to end what she calls the “Prison-Industrial Complex.” This is a racist campaign to free every incarcerated criminal in the United States who happens to be of a darker skin tone. Her movement is actually doubly racist.  First, because it singles out black and Hispanic criminals for “liberation,” and second, because ninety-five percent of their crimes are committed against law-abiding black and Hispanic people. Angela Davis is a “University Professor,” which means that she makes a six-figure income, is provided with a personal staff and is honored in a way that only a select few of University of California  faculty are. A revered figure among the academic left, she makes scores of appearances every academic year and receiving $10,000 honoraria an appearance to spread her hatred of white people, of Jews, and of America to college audiences. This evening we have been thrust into a very sad situation.

Ecclesiastes famously said, “There is nothing new under the sun,” and the older I get, the more impressed I am by this observation. My own parents were card-carrying members of the American Communist Party, which meant that they were pawns, witting and unwitting, of the Soviet empire.  They called themselves progressives and believed they had joined a movement to bring social justice to all mankind. In 1956, the leader of world Communism gave a secret speech about the crimes that Stalin had committed in the name of social justice, which included the murders of millions of people, including millions of Communists. He gave the speech because the post-Stalin leaders of the Soviet Union were afraid a new Stalin would emerge and slaughter them too. Like today’s leftists, my parents hated the anti-Communists on the political right and called them liars when they confronted progressives with the crimes their hero had committed. The anti-Communists claimed that Stalin had killed 10 million people. In fact, when the truth was revealed, the figure was 40 million.  That’s interesting in itself:  The right understates the truth, and the left overstates the lies, in the name of social justice.

When the speech appeared on the front page of The New York Times, its impact was devastating to the progressive cause to which my parents had devoted themselves. Progressives were demoralized and unable to regroup. So their children — my generation — launched a new left.  We fatuously believed that there could be a new left – one untainted by the crimes of the old and unlikely to repeat them despite the fact that our understanding of the world and our agenda for the future — social justice, meaning equality enforced by government — were fundamentally the same. The American founders understood and asserted that politically enforced equality would mean the end of liberty for all, a wisdom we ignored as the new left quickly revealed itself to be no different from the old, embracing Communists in Vietnam and Central America and eventually Islamic totalitarians in Gaza and the Middle East.

About the time I was having lunch with Herbert Marcuse, I was also raising a considerable sum of money for the Black Panther Party in order to buy a church in East Oakland to house a Panther school. I was then the editor of Ramparts, the largest magazine of the left, and had recruited our bookkeeper, Betty Van Patter, to maintain the school’s financial records because I foolishly believed our own propaganda that a “racist” federal government would shut down the school if the Panthers didn’t keep their books properly. In December 1974, Betty Van Patter disappeared, and by the time the police fished her body out of San Francisco Bay, I knew the Panthers had killed her, and I also knew that every progressive friend I had was a potential threat to me and my four children, because if I said what I thought, members of that community would denounce me as a CIA agent and a racist, and I couldn’t know what consequences might ensue.

So for me Israel Apartheid Week where secular progressives join hands with theocratic fascists and disregard the realities in front of their eyes is a case of déjà vu all over again.  On this campus we are witnessing a “protest” in support of a movement worse than the Nazis, which unlike Hitler broadcasts from the rooftops its plan to obliterate the Jews, to obliterate Israel and to obliterate America. Have you noticed a single Muslim country distancing itself from this plan or denouncing Ahmadinejad and Hizbollah and Hamas for proclaiming this solution to the problem posed by infidel Jews and Americans? Even one Muslim state out of the 57 that exist? When people say Islam is a religion of peace, I’m sure that’s true for some individual Muslims, and have said so many times.  But when you look at the organized Muslim community, the element that is willing to stand up for peace, that will defend the right of the Jewish state to exist, that is willing to pass a UN resolution condemning the genocidal terrorists of Hizbollah and Hamas is so inconsequential that it might as well not exist.

Now to the conflict in the Middle East which Israel Apartheid Week is supposed to illuminate. Since there are young people in this room I’m going to focus this lesson on a recent event — the 2005 Israeli withdrawal from Gaza. Gaza is a little strip of land bounded on one side by the Mediterranean and on the other by Israel. It is about six miles wide and 25 miles long.  Across this stretch of land, Israel was attacked by Egyptian tanks in three aggressive wars supported by all the Arabs in the region – in 1948, 1967 and 1973. Since Gaza is a long corridor the support of its population for the anti-Israel aggressor gave Egyptian forces the opportunity to come within striking range of important Israeli cities. This is why in the aftermath of those aggressions Israel decided it was necessary for security reasons to station Israeli forces in Gaza.

Not only did Egypt invade Israel three times across the Gaza strip, but after the first invasion it annexed Gaza, and did so with no protest from Palestinians or the Arab world, which now pretend to be so concerned about Palestinian land and a Palestinian state. Following the 1948 war, when Gaza was under Egyptian control, the 25 mile strip of land became the base for the first terrorist attacks against Israeli civilians. These were conducted by the Fedayeen who were created by Egypt’s dictator, Gamel Abdel Nasser, and were led by the head of his secret police.

These and later terrorist attacks by the PLO and Hamas strengthened Israel’s resolve to take the step that any country would take to protect its citizens by stationing its own military in the Gaza strip until such a time as the Arab states and the Palestinians were ready to accept Israel’s existence and live in peace. It has been more than sixty years since the creation of Israel and the Arabs have never been willing to accept Israel’s existence and consequently there is no peace.  No Palestinian entity recognizes the state of Israel. None. Israel has been continuously under attack by Arab regimes and Arab terrorists since its creation. The Islamic Republic of Iran, armed with Chinese rockets and soon to possess nuclear weapons has declared its intention to wipe Israel from the face of the earth. The Palestinian Authority, Hizbollah, and Hamas have made the identical intention clear so that no one can mistake it. These calls for genocide have not been repudiated by a single Muslim state, and no Muslim state has offered Israel’s threatened Jews their support.

Nonetheless, in 2005, Israel, in the interests of peace, unilaterally withdrew its military forces from Gaza, taking a risk unprecedented in the annals of nations.  The events that followed the Israeli withdrawal tell you everything you need to know about the Palestinians and their cause, and about the nature of the conflict in the Middle East.

Prior to Israel’s withdrawal, there were 9,000 Jews living in Gaza along the Mediterranean coast. Nine thousand Jews out of a population of 1.2 million Arabs; nine thousand law-abiding Jews.  These 9,000 law-abiding Jews created a horticulture industry, which employed 12,000 Palestinians and whose product accounted for 10% of the entire gross national product of Gaza.  Consider that 9,000 Jews are only .02% of the Gaza population. Two hundredths of 1%.  As it happens the entire state of Israel also exists on only .02% of the entire Arab land mass. But that is too much for the Arabs. And nine thousand Jews out of a population of 1.2 million Arabs was too much for them as well.

Think about it. If the Muslims of Gaza – or if the leaders they have elected — were rational, decent, normal human beings their reaction to the law-abiding Jews living among them could have been: Let’s import more Jews!  Let’s encourage more Jews to live here. Let’s make Jews welcome in our country; they are creating so much wealth for our citizens.

But that did not happen. Instead the Israeli government out of concern for the safety of the 9,000 productive, law-abiding Jews who lived there, evacuated them from Gaza. Some of these Jews were so attached to their homes in Gaza that they had to be removed at gun point. Why did the Israeli government do that? Because if they left them behind they would have been slaughtered.  Everybody, including those individuals in this audience who disagree with everything else I say, should understand that. Palestinians elect regimes – both the PLO and Hamas – which organize terrorist attacks against men, women and children; which target men, women and children. No civilized people in the world does that. Everybody understands that if the Palestinians were disarmed today, there would be peace in the Middle East.  Everybody understands that if the Jews in Israel disarm, they will be massacred.  These are simple facts that every rational person can see provided their vision isn’t impaired by religious hatred.

It was even worse than these bare facts would suggest. A philanthropic Jew in America, Mortimer Zuckerman, the publisher of U.S. News and World Report, fully aware that the Jews of Gaza were going to be removed forcibly to save their lives because the Palestinians are so bloodthirsty and genocidal that Israel couldn’t guarantee their safety, collected $14 million from American Jews to buy the 3,000 greenhouses and all the plumbing that went into this horticulture industry. They then gave it to the Palestinians as a gesture of peace.  And on the day that Hamas took control of Gaza, the Palestinians destroyed all the greenhouses, all the plumbing, and started firing thousands of rockets into unarmed towns and schoolyards in Israel.

Every Palestinian rocket is an anti-civilian rocket because they are rockets that can’t be aimed. The Palestinians fire their rockets at random in the hopes that they will kill Jews. Israel’s rockets, by contrast, are precision weapons that are aimed solely at military targets in an effort save civilian lives.

The lesson of the Gaza Strip is that the Palestinian jihadists are so full of hate that they are willing to destroy 10% of their own gross national product because it was created and donated by Jews. Israel, the on the other hand, was forced to evacuate the people who created this wealth to save them from being massacred because they were Jews.  That tells you everything you need to know about the conflict in the Middle East.

Here’s another instructive fact about Gaza. After the 1948 war, the entire Gaza Strip was annexed by Egypt. It disappeared from the maps. The same thing happened to the West Bank, which was annexed by Jordan. Yet there was no protest from the Arabs or the “Palestinians.” So much for the desire for Palestinian self-determination.

The so-called Palestine Liberation Organization was created in 1964, fifteen years after the creation of Israel. This was the first time since the Arabs invaded the region in the 7th Century that there was any hint there was a people who identified themselves as “Palestinians” and desired a Palestinian state.

The charter of the newly created PLO which proclaimed the goals of the “liberation” movement failed to mention either the annexation of the West Bank or the Gaza strip. There was not a word in it about the liberation of Gaza from Egypt. There was not a word about the liberation of the West Bank from Jordan. Instead the PLO charter called for the elimination of the “Zionist entity.” From its beginning the Palestinian liberation movement has been a movement driven by Jew hatred. It is not designed to liberate the Palestinians by winning them a state; it is designed to “liberate” Israel and the Arab Middle East from the Jews, to expunge an infidel presence from the Muslim umma. Hamas and Hizbollah and the PLO do not want a Palestinian state. They want an Islamic empire, an infidel-free zone stretching “from the Jordan to the sea.”

Now allow me to deal with some of the lies perpetrated by the Muslim Students Association and their “Israel Apartheid Week” on this campus.  On the “apartheid” wall of hate funded by this university there is a map that pictures Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.  It is labeled “occupied Palestine.” It is a lie.

There is no occupation of a country called “Palestine.”  There were no Palestinian lands originally to be stolen.  Israel was created in the same way that Jordan, Syria, Lebanon, and Iraq were created – out of the ruins of the Turkish Empire.  The Turks are not Arabs.  They had ruled the entire region for 400 years since the 16th Century, until they joined the powers that were defeated in World War I.

At the end of the war, the victors – Britain and France — divided up the spoils, in this case the defeated Turkish empire. The “Palestine Mandate,” which was part of these Turkish spoils did not refer to a people but to a geographical region. The people in the region for the previous thousand years called themselves “Arabs” not “Palestinians.” The word “Palestine” is not even an Arab word. It is Roman in origin. When the Romans drove the Jews out of their homeland, Judea, in the first century CE, they renamed it after the Jews’ enemies, the Philistines, who were Europeans, not Arabs. Hence the name “Palestine.”

The claim that Israel is “occupied Palestine” is a lie of Hitlerian proportions and has the same genocidal intention. And it is funded by the University of California on this campus.

A second version of this lie is focused on Jewish settlements in the West Bank, as though these are an extension of the so-called “occupation.” The hate week displays put up by the Muslim Students Association, show the West Bank dotted with the settlements of Jewish interlopers. Let me put to you this question: If you are not a xenophobe or a racist what is wrong with Jewish settlements – with Jews settling on the West Bank or in Gaza? Why is a Jewish settlement a problem?  There are more than a million Arab Muslims settled permanently in Israel as Israeli citizens. They have more rights than the Muslims of Gaza, more rights than the Muslims in the West Bank, more rights than the Muslims in Iran, more rights than the Muslims in any Muslim country.  Jews welcome Muslims as settlers in their country. But Arab Muslims do not welcome Jews. They are xenophobes and Judeo-phobes, and that is the only reason why Jewish settlements are a problem for them.

Consider that the Jews of Israel have been attacked in a single generation in three aggressive wars designed to push them into the sea. By every precept of international law they had – and have — the right to annex those territories from which they were attacked and expel the entire population which joined the aggressions.

That’s exactly what happened to the Germans after World War II. East Prussia was the industrial heartland of Germany. Ethnic Germans had inhabited it for 1,000 years. But when Germany invaded Poland twice in a generation, the allied powers said, enough.  As part of the peace that followed the war, they expelled 12 million Germans from East Prussia and gave the land they had inhabited to Poland. There was no international outcry over that.

The Israelis had every right to take the same measures to secure peace in the Middle East in 1948 and 1967. In 1948 they could have expelled all the Arabs who had not left Israel, the way the Arabs expelled the Jews living in their countries in the Middle East. In 1967 they could have expelled all the Arabs living in Gaza and all the Arabs on the West Bank. But they didn’t. They preferred to live in peace with their Arab neighbors. The Israelis extended their hands to them and even when their peace offers were rejected built universities on the West Bank and made it a booming economy – an economy the PLO has since destroyed. And now the Israelis are being threatened with extinction by these same people as a reward for their generosity.

A third lie featured in the Muslim-sponsored hate fest this week is that there are five million Palestinian refugees who should be returned to their homes in Israel. The Arab records show quite clearly that when the Arab armies invaded Israel, the Arab governments called on those Arabs living in the area to flee and promised them they would be returned to their homes by the victorious Arab armies. In war, people sometimes flee because they are scared; some were undoubtedly driven out. Eventually there were an estimated five or six hundred thousand Arabs who fled. But there were also six hundred thousand Jews who were driven out of Iraq, Morocco, Tunisia and other Arab lands where they had lived for centuries. The largest ethnic community in Baghdad until the 30’s, when Iraq joined the Nazis, was the Jews.

The Arab propagandists and their University of California supporters now claim that there are more than five million Palestinian refugees, even though there were only a tenth that many originally and most of them have died. But why are there any Palestinian refugees? It is sixty years later. There are no longer any Jewish refugees, because they were all re-settled by Israel. The Palestinian refugees were not re-settled by the Arabs, not even in Jordan whose territory consists of 80% of the original Palestine Mandate and whose population is 70% made up of Palestinian Arabs. Jordan by the way is ruled by a Hashemite minority, yet there are no calls for the self-determination of Palestinians in Jordan. Palestinian Arabs are not allowed to settle in other Arab states. They are barred from entering.

In other words, the reason there are Palestinian refugees is because the PLO, Hamas and the Arab states want them to be refugees — want them to be confined to miserable camps, where they can use them for propaganda and as cannon fodder for the war to cleanse the Jews from the Muslim Middle East. Indeed the refugee camps are bases for the terrorist armies of the Islamic jihad. The United States and Israel, along with other countries, have poured billions of dollars into the refugee cause and it ended up in the Swiss bank accounts of the real oppressors of Palestinians – the leaders of the PLO and Hamas. Yasir Arafat died with a Swiss bank account worth $35 billion. That was money donated by Jews and Americans and taken out of the pockets of Palestinians.

The centerpiece of the Muslim sponsored hate week on this campus is the so-called Apartheid Wall which is itself two lies. The wall being protested – the “wall” in Israel — is not a wall but a security fence, and it is not an “apartheid” fence because it is not designed to enforce a separation of races or ethnicities. There are, as noted, a million Arabs living in Israel with more rights than the Arabs of any Arab country.

The fence was not erected to keep Arabs out. It was erected to keep terrorists out. The West Bank and Gaza are terrorist camps whose governments honor, support, and orchestrate a terrorist war against the ordinary citizens of Israel. What if the Jews took down the wall? We know from the past exactly what would happen. Israel’s security fence did not appear out of the blue.  The wall was a desperate last measure the Israelis devised after years of watching their children slaughtered by Palestinians in discos and at Sbarro pizza parlors who were then honored as heroes and martyrs in the wake of their crimes. The fence has stopped virtually all of these attacks. So what the hate week on this campus is really calling for when it calls for the removal of the fence is a renewal of terrorist attacks against the children of Israel.

There are whole departments of this university that are sponsoring this hate week and thus the war against the Jews it encourages, including the Visual Arts Department, the Literature Department and the Ethnic Studies Department. The Thurgood Marshall College is another official entity sponsoring these incitements and lies. If you look at the codes this university claims to live by, you will see that chief among them is respect for diversity – for the ethnicities of students who attend this school. There is no respect for Jewish students at this campus when a week of hate like this is thrust in their faces courtesy of university faculties and administrators.

There are thirty campuses across the nation hosting Israel Apartheid Weeks this spring, including the University of California — Irvine, UC Berkeley, Boston University, Brandeis. Brown, University of Wisconsin, University of Houston, Brooklyn College, University of Chicago, UC Santa Barbara, UC Santa Cruz, UCLA, DePaul, Columbia, University of Illinois, University of Minnesota, University of Washington and others.

Behind each and every one of these hate weeks against the Jews is the Muslim Students Association. Many people on this and other campuses mistake the Muslim Students Association for a cultural organization that represents all Muslims. It is no such thing. The Muslim Students Association is a sister organization of the terrorist organization Hamas, and like Hamas, is part of the Muslim Brotherhood network.

Hasan al-Banna, the founder of the Muslim Brotherhood and the architect of terrorist jihad was an admirer of Adolf Hitler, whose organization translated Mein Kampf into Arabic. The father of Palestinian nationalism, Haj Amin al-Husseini, was one of Al-Banna’s heroes and is revered to this day by the Palestinian Authority and Hamas as the father of Palestinian nationalism. Haj Amin al-Husseini was a Nazi. In the twenties and the thirties he preached the extermination of the Jews and inspired two celebrated massacres of Jewish settlers. During the Second World War he went to Berlin to work with Hitler to recruit Arabs to Nazism . He devised his own plan to create an Auschwitz in the Middle East and was thwarted in setting up his death camps only because Rommel was defeated at El-Alamein. After the war, he and al-Banna led the Arab crusade against the creation of the Jewish state.

Why is the Muslim Students Association that violates the diversity principles and ethical codes of every one of these universities allowed to sponsor hate weeks against Israel and the Jews on these campuses? Where is the outrage over the lies the Muslim Students Association spreads along with its incitements against the Jewish state? Shame on the University of California for its role in this event. Shame on Thurgood Marshall College and the faculties that sponsored it. And shame on the Muslim students who use the shield of their religion to advance the Islamic war against the Jews.

A Question from the Audience:

[Note: I am including this one question from a UC San Diego student named Jumanah Imad Albahri, a former officer of the Muslim Students Association. Albahri came wearing a red Muslim head covering and a Kaffiya, the scarf Arafat used as a symbol of the terrorist war against Israel. A video of this exchange is available here]

Jumanah Imad Albahri: Good evening.  I just wanted to say thank you for coming to campus tonight and presenting your point of view.  It’s always valuable to have two sets of views going on at the same time. Very useful. My name is Jumanah Imad Albahri and I am a student here at UCSD.  I was reading your literature. I found that much more interesting than the talk. And I found some interesting things about the MSA, which is an organization that is very active on campus and it is hosting our annual “Hitler Youth Week.”  You should come out to those events.  If you could clarify the connection between the MSA and Jihad terrorist networks, because last I checked, we had to do our own fundraising and we never get help from anyone.  So if you could clarify the connection between UCSD’s MSA, or if you don’t have such information, if you could connect other MSAs on UC, because the connection wasn’t too clear in the pamphlet.

David Horowitz: Will you condemn Hamas here and now?

Jumanah Imad Albahri: I’m sorry, what?

Horowitz: Will you condemn Hamas?

Albahri: Would I condemn Hamas?

Horowitz: As a terrorist – genocidal — organization?

Albahri: Are you asking me to put myself on a cross?

Horowitz: So you won’t.  I actually have had this experience many times.  You didn’t read the pamphlet (The Muslim Student Association and the Jihad Network), because the pamphlet gives chapter and verse on the connection.  The main connection is that the MSA is part of the Muslim Brotherhood network as revealed in the documents produced by the FBI in the Holy Land Foundation trial.

Albahri: I don’t think you understood what I meant by that.  I meant, if I say something, I’m sure that I will be arrested for reasons of Homeland Security.  So if you could please just answer my question.

Horowitz: If you condemn Hamas, Homeland Security will arrest you?

Albahri: If I support Hamas — because your question forces me to condemn Hamas — if I support Hamas, I look really bad.

Horowitz: Well, if you don’t condemn Hamas, obviously you support it. Case closed. I had this same experience at UC Santa Barbara where there were 50 members of the Muslim Students Association sitting right in the rows there. And throughout my hour talk, I kept asking them, will you condemn Hezbollah and Hamas.  And none of them would.  And then, when the question period came, the President of the Muslim Students Association was the first person to ask questions. And I said, before you start, will you condemn Hezbollah?  And he said, well, that question is too complicated for a yes/no answer.  So I said, okay, I’ll put it to you this way. I am a Jew. The head of Hezbollah has said that he hopes that we will gather in Israel so he doesn’t have to hunt us down globally. For it or against it?

Albahri: For it.

Horowitz: Thank you. Thank you for coming and showing everybody what’s really going on here.

  • mike

    why US does not help all Israeli's to move over to US

    • kafir4life

      If we could trade….could we get all the muslims to leave the US? Maybe even a deal with other countries that are fed up with the presense of moon god worshipping, pedophile emulating muslims…….Get them all to the arabian peninsula? Then they will be gathered in one place. Right?

      You must be the dullard mikey from texas the pedophile emulating moon god worshipper, yes?

      allahahahaha snackbar!

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/Stephen_Brady Stephen_Brady

      Maybe because the Israelis don't want to live in the US. Instead, they want to live in their own country.

      Allow me propose another solution to you. Why doesn't Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, Egypt, and all the other Muslim nations help all the PALs to move to their countries, and assimilate them into their culture? No Palestinians dying and "suffering", and no Jews dying and suffering.

      Cool solution, in my estimation …

      …. Alas. It won't happen. The PALs are more useful to the Muslim nations as pawns in a regional game of chess …

      • shanie

        good stuff
        Weldon stephen "No Palestinians dying and "suffering", and no Jews dying and suffering. "

  • Kim Bruce

    Thank you, David.
    Thank you for posting your entire speech. It was very clarifying, to the point and it is my sincere hope that more students get to hear your lectures and that they really think long and hard about what is happening not just in the Middle-East but what is happening world-wide, particularly here in North America.
    We have student campuses here in Canada that celebrate Israeli-aprtheid week.
    I wish you could come to speak at some of those campuses.

  • Kim Bruce

    David,
    May I have permission to send your lecture to my member of parliament?

  • http://www.CompellingConversations.com Eric Roth

    Thank you for giving that long, detailed, and quite insightful primer on the motives and methods of the growing Islamist movement on American college campuses. A combination of naivety, willful blindness, a historical thinking, and ethnic hatred are leading too many so-called progressives into supporting violent, religious bigots under some perverted notions of social justice. This article provides missing context, connects the dots, and illuminates the dangers.

    And I'm going to follow your lead and call the MSA's week long protests "Hitler Youth Week" to emphasize their genocidal ambitions.

  • ze-ev ben jehudah

    I worked for several years in Israel.A small village,with a small hospital.
    Israeli's and Palestinians lived nearly next door to each other and most
    Palestinian and Israeli childeren and grown ups called each other,
    uncle and aunty and walked in and out their houses like equals.
    Most men and woman in the street are deadly afraid and won't protest.
    I have a daughter in law from Russia an she lived during the communist
    regime in in Moskau and you know!! that people were deadly afraid to
    say anything wrongly about that regime!! not even against their own
    family!!! So put you neck shots somewhere else please.

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/The_Inquisitor The_Inquisitor

    I second all these comments in praise of your speech. It was excellent.

  • Tanstaafl

    Bravo! Bravo!

  • sflbib

    There was a story on the news this morning [5/28] about the U.S training Palestinian "security" forces. Are we out of our minds? We're training terrorists for the next attack on Israel.

  • USMCSniper

    David told her exactly where she stood: "Well, if you don’t condemn Hamas, obviously you support it. Case closed."

  • Andres de Alamaya

    We need new legislation that forbids universities and schools of any type to accept donations by foreign governments, foreign political or religious organizations which will remove the blinders worn by academic whores and school administrators.
    MSA is one of a number of what can be called Trojan Horse organizations designed to convert and subjugate America. If federal, or state governments and/or school administrations don't curb, reject, and eliminate these very obvious Trojan Horses, the people of America will. The growth of heavily armed American militias has been astounding of late and while this growth can become a worry to peaceful, law abiding citizenry, it should also give Muslims in America with a Fedayeen mindset a great deal of concern. Their bent to play victim could turn to very real and dramatic reality. They don't understand the slumbering American DNA which has the potential of catastrophic eruption giving a new dimension to "nakba."

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/topperj topperj

    Our colleges and universities have become cesspools. Expensive ones.

  • Andres de Alamaya

    P.S. While I don't feel there is any point in debating with Muslim Hitler Youth Organizations, it might provide some perspective to readers at large to point out that so-called "Apartheid" is not an evil thing. It is simply sensible. Americans living in gated communities practice Apartheid to protect themselves from robbers, rapists and murderers. The South Africans practiced it for their protection for the same reasons. South Africa today is in far worse shape. One of history's greatest structural achievements is the Great Wall of China which ran 5,500 miles (Hint to Homeland Security: it is only 1,550 miles from San Diego to Brownsville, TX) The Chinese built the wall to protect themselves from repeated invasions by nomadic barbarians. The wall that Israel built was to keep out lunatic suicide bombers and it has worked. Foolishly Israel has given citizenship to a huge and rapidly growing number of Muslim Arabs who enjoy more freedoms than they would in any Muslim lands, their home approved Trojan Horse. When you move to another seat on a train or bus because the person next to you has a foul smell, you are practicing Apartheid. When you avoid a hapless bore you are practicing Apartheid. When you opt not to walk through a dark alley in a bad district, you are practicing Apartheid – and in each of these cases the word could be exchanged for common sense. When American students and universities begin to practice Apartheid vis-a-vis the MSA, the future of America will be improved.
    The time has come for America to begin to practice some Apartheid starting with an overhaul of immigration laws that will keep out those who are committed to convert or vanquish America.

    • Mary Ann Clark

      I am 70 yrs. old and apartheid is, has always been, and will always be the destruction of a particular culture or race with the ultimate goal of wiping them off the face of the earth. If Muslims and Arabs believe in God, then why do they not follow His example in all things??? Love your neighbor as you love yourself, thou shalt not kill, thou shall not have any other Gods before me, and the list goes on.

      Instead they have become a hateful people that want to dominate the world, and have everyone believe as they do or die. What God do they believe in??? There is only one God.

  • ron

    As a Jew I feel such a sense of choking oppression from the hate and lies directed at me. Reading what you wrote is like breathing air for the first time.

    Thank you. You are my brother.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/RogueWave24 RogueWave24

      Amen.

  • Carolina Don

    Thank You for the very insightful details that you gave. I have studied the history of Israel a great deal, but when it came to more modern history I was left in a fog. Thanks for filling in many blanks for me. I pray God will bless Israel.

  • John Z52

    "Professor Herbert Marcuse, a malicious Marxist who made a reputation for himself and became a hero to the left by advancing the proposition that if you can claim to speak on behalf of the oppressed you have the right and the obligation to silence, and, if necessary, to obliterate people who disagree with you. This, of course, is the creed of every run-of-the-mill dictator on earth, and it is the creed of the progressive left today.

    With his own words Horowitz shows Israel for what they are, a fascist state that has a media blackout on nearly everything that has to do with Palestinian house demolitions, arrests and the slaughter of innocent Palestinian civilians.

    • charles

      John Z52. Ignorance is bliss for you. It is too you are so ignorant of who the Jews are. The are the only Democratic State in the Middle East. They are the only Democratic State in the Middle East that has claim to many religions. They have Israeli citizens who are Arabs. Can you as insolent idiot make that claim about Hamas (Gaza) and the West Bank? Do Israeli's shoot rockets from schools and hospitals to aggressively go after the terrorist.

      John, scientifically, I know amoeba has more critical thinking skills than you would ever have. Get your head and ass wired right and study what is going on, learn the facts and quite being stupid.

  • susan

    what concerns me is that there is very little vocal opposition to these "events" that are occuring at numerous universities across the country. particularly distressing is
    the silence from jewish organizations that are supposed to do just that. one such organization, the jewish anti-defamation league and its president abe foxman, are going after newt gingrich for his comparisons of the nazi regime and the obama administration in the context that they are similar in structure and organization. foxman claims gingrich is demeaning the holocaust in his comparisons, which in the content of gingrichs' argument, is not only unfair but erroneous. foxman claims to abhor the use ofmoral equivalence between nazi germany and other issues in the nations political discourse but amazingly he is silent at the myriad of moral equivalency posturing from the left. i guess foxman's political leanings determine what constitutes moral outrage. the political left in this country is by definition anti-semitic and pro-muslim. everyone, especially american jews, better wake up and start taking this seriously or history just might repeat itself.

    • Neil

      David Horowitz, at the helm of the ADL, would give that organization the respect that it once commanded and deserved. Unfortunately, Foxman goes after Gingrich, Limbaugh and Beck and ignores true Jew haters, the so-called "progressive left." Absolutely shameful!

      • ajnn

        YES !!!!!!

  • Douglas Reed

    Actually, the Philistines were Myceneans fleeing a catastrophe on the island of Crete (rather large earthquake as I recall). European, maybe, maybe not. Definitely not Arab.

  • hoppy

    That superb chapter must be appeared in pre written essay, because that is easy to digital transcription choosing the good writing services.

  • Peter E. Coleman

    The politics of separate but equal marches on. Progressing the misery that only social justice can provide. Create Minorities while encouraging their axe grinding. Create Pigeon holes where all can be classified and vilified. The Jews just happen to hold the original deed in the coops development.

    Hitler started with the biggest stakeholder then just added holes as he went along. The rest just waited in place by the false hope the homing variety gave them. Their brothers were not really gone. They just haven't come back yet.

    Hitler never died-He just re-spawned.

  • Charles

    David:

    Great article, it shows that fascism in alive and well in the United States. It shows how the Left has a hold on colleges. College students seem to be gullible to ideals without thinking. There are those that are astute and understand the situation. The lady who gave her anti-semite oratory as noted above be subjected to an honor killing if she was raped by another man. Stupidity knows no bounds.

    The whole situation that is happening not only in our country, but, at our schools reminds me of what happened in our country before we went to war with Germany and how the Nazi's in our country were rallying around anti-semitism. It happened in my hometown.

    Arizona's new immigration law is the first step. The next step is dealing with the Muslim's in our country. Below is a letter from a Holocaust survivor:

  • charles

    A Letter from a Holocaust Survivor – Part !

    Holocaust Survivor's View on Fanatic Islam

    This is one of the best explanation of the Muslim terrorist situation
    I have read. His references to past history are accurate and clear.
    Not long, easy to understand, and well worth the read.
    The author of this email is Dr. Emanuel Tanay, a well-known
    and well respected psychiatrist.
    ________________________________________

    A Holocaust Survivor's View on Islam
    A man, whose family was German aristocracy prior to World War II, owned a number of large industries and estates. When asked how many German people were true Nazis, the answer he gave can guide our attitude toward fanaticism. 'Very few people were true Nazis,' he said, 'but many enjoyed the return of German pride, and many more were too busy to care. I was one of those who just thought the Nazis were a bunch of fools. So, the majority just sat back and let it all happen. Then, before we knew it, they owned us, and we had lost control, and the end of the world had come. My family lost everything. I ended up in a concentration camp and the Allies destroyed my factories.'

  • charles

    A Holocaus Survivor's View On Islam_Part II

    We are told again and again by 'experts' and 'talking heads' that Islam is the religion of peace and that the vast majority of Muslims just want to live in peace. Although this unqualified assertion may be true, it is entirely irrelevant. It is meaningless fluff, meant to make us feel better, and meant to somehow diminish the specter of fanatics rampaging across the globe in the name of Islam.

    The fact is that the fanatics rule Islam at this moment in history. It is the fanatics who march… It is the fanatics who wage any one of 50 shooting wars worldwide. It is the fanatics who systematically slaughter Christian or tribal groups throughout Africa and are gradually taking over the entire continent in an Islamic wave. It is the fanatics who bomb, behead, murder, or honor-kill. It is the fanatics who take over mosque after mosque. It is the fanatics who zealously spread the stoning and hanging of rape victims and homosexuals. It is the fanatics who teach their young to kill and to become suicide bombers.

    The hard, quantifiable fact is that the peaceful majority, the 'silent majority,' is cowed and extraneous.

  • charles

    A Holocaust Survivor's View On Islam_Part III

    Communist Russia was comprised of Russians who just wanted to live in peace, yet the Russian Communists were responsible for the murder of about 20 million people. The peaceful majority were irrelevant. China's huge population was peaceful as well, but Chinese Communists managed to kill a staggering 70 million people.

    The average Japanese individual prior to World War II was not a warmongering sadist. Yet, Japan murdered and slaughtered its way across South East Asia in an orgy of killing that included the systematic murder of 12 million Chinese civilians; most killed by sword, shovel, and bayonet.

    And who can forget Rwanda , which collapsed into butchery. Could it not be said that the majority of Rwandans were 'peace loving'?

    History lessons are often incredibly simple and blunt, yet for all our powers of reason, we often miss the most basic and uncomplicated of points:

    Peace-loving Muslims have been made irrelevant by their silence.

  • charles

    A Holocaust Survivor's View On Islam_Part IV

    Peace-loving Muslims will become our enemy if they don't speak up, because like my friend from Germany , they will awaken one day and find that the fanatics own them, and the end of their world will have begun.

    Peace-loving Germans, Japanese, Chinese, Russians, Rwandans, Serbs, Afghans, Iraqis, Palestinians, Somalis, Nigerians, Algerians, and many others have died because the peaceful majority did not speak up until it was too late. As for us who watch it all unfold, we must pay attention to the only group that counts — the fanatics who threaten our way of life.

    Lastly, anyone who doubts that the issue is serious and just deletes this email without sending it on is contributing to the passiveness that allows the problems to expand. So, extend yourself a bit and send this on and on and on! Let us hope that thousands, world-wide, read this and think about it, and send it on – before it's too late.

  • charles

    A Holocaust Survivor's View On Islam_Part V

    Emanuel Tanay, M.D. 2980 Provincial St. Ann Arbor , MI 48104
    *Dr. Emanuel Tanay MD <http://www..icle.org/directory/contrib_bios.cfm?&Pnumber=F90113> is a well-known forensic psychiatrist who has been an expert witness in many famous cases. He has served as an officer or committee member on the Michigan Psychiatric Society, the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law, the American Psychiatric Association (APA), and others. He is a diplomate of the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology and of the American Board of Forensic Psychiatry and a distinguished fellow of the APA and the American Academy of Forensic Sciences (AAFC).

    A Holocaust survivor himself, Dr Tanay coauthored a book about the survivors of the Holocaust and was asked by the German governmen t to consult on just compensation for the Holocaust survivors. Dr. Tanay has served on several journal editorial boards, authored many publications, and presented countless times on forensic medicine. His efforts have also produced many awards and commendations from groups such as the Michigan State Medical Society, APA, the Detroit Institute of Technology, and AAFC, among others.

  • Napzilla

    The skill with which Horowitz twists facts and arguments to serve his own ends must come in handy at Harvard, where the next generation of the ruling class is indoctrinated and prepared to assume control of the world's most powerful war industry. Finkelstein was right about this clown, he's nothing more than a liar and a two-bit fraud. But, then, I don't really have to bother pointing that out, as Israel's terrible human rights record–which Horowitz so readily defends–really speaks for itself.

    • Helen Spilatro

      People like you need to go back to school and get some education. You gotta be living in a coma not to see the truth.very sad that this world fills up with ignorant, uneducated people like yourself.

  • WRJonas

    The people smearing Mr. Horowitz on this site are classic liars and deceivers. They never offer a valid defense or proof of their assertions. Mr Horowitz provides clear, logical, provable facts to support the statements he makes so they only tactic left to his detractors is to smear with innuendo.
    What facts has he distorted or taken out context ? Which historical episode has he misinterpreted ? Which conclusion he draws is not true?
    He has admitted through his earlier associations in life that he has participated in and knows intimately the methods and objectives of the global left.
    They are the evil purveyors of hate and destruction . No disguise is adequate to conceal them . They are the children of Satan himself and we see them in their shame and hatefulness.

  • Bob S

    I just watched the complete speech via podcast and, though I have not seen many DH speeches, and though this speech may be par for the course for him, I consider this to be one of the most powerful and important speeches of my adult life.

  • http://www.woodedpaths.com DWPittelli

    Great speech.

    I have one nit to pick: 9,000 is 0.75%, not 0.02%, of 1.2 million.

  • Democracy First

    Napzilla, yours is classic ad hominem attack, just the tactic for those who can't prove their point, so smear those whose reasoning frustrates them so.

    That this is all you have against DH only substantiates his arguments all the more.

  • Angela

    The Jews will never be defeated.

    The reason is based on a verse in Genesis in which God, referring to the Jewish people, says to Abraham: “I will bless those who bless you and curse those who curse you.”

    One need not be a Jew or Christian or even believe in God to appreciate that this verse is as accurate a prediction as humanity has ever been given by the ancient world. The Jewish people have suffered longer and more horribly than any other living people. But they are still around. Its historic enemies are all gone. Those that cursed the Jews were indeed cursed.

    The Jew-Hating Muslims will eventually be gone. It's only a matter of time.

    • Ariel

      Amen Angela! Very soon, when all the nations of the world, most of which will be Muslim, come against Israel, the Almighty Creator of heaven and earth will roar, "ENOUGH!!" He has been watching all these many years of injustice, lying, inhumanity, etc. The Jews are the apple of His eye, Jerusalem is His holy city forever and vengeance is His.

  • Long Ben

    Like it or not , there must now and in the future be a Jewish presence in Israel and Jerusalem in particular. To the end that the Prophecy in Zechariah 12 : 10 come to pass !

  • Rick

    We are truly blessed to have people like David in our midst. May God bless him and give him a very long life.

  • Charles Alexander

    What's missing is the same as was missing in the 1930's.

    Why aren't there 150 strong Jewish students filling the front rows of the auditorium, prepared to shout back at the MSA and ready to stand in force to physically defend David if it comes to it?

  • http://usaconstruction.net construction

    Hi, i feel that i noticed you visited my site so i got here to go back the desire?.I’m attempting to in finding issues to enhance my website!I assume its good enough to make use of a few of your ideas!!

  • Rena B.

    To thungurkifur, whatever your stupid user name is: You are a hateful idiot. You didn't understand this speech/article at all.