Apologist for Gender Apartheid

On May 7, 2010, UCLA’s Center for Near Eastern Studies (CNES) and the Journal of Middle East Women’s Studies co-sponsored the lecture, “Rethinking Arab Women as ‘Subjects.’” The talk was delivered by Suad Joseph, a Lebanese-born professor of anthropology and women’s studies at UC Davis, and president-elect of the Middle East Studies Association (MESA), the principal professional organization for scholars of the region. Joseph, who has co-edited a book with CNES director Susan Slyomovics, is considered a pioneer in the field of Middle East women’s studies, accolades which—as is, sadly, often the case—translates into apologetics for the oppression of Middle Eastern women.

Joseph announced she was perturbed about the title of her lecture; she couldn’t decide whether “Arab” was an appropriate term to use for identification purposes. Yet, she contradicted herself (and followed the Arabist practice of her discipline) by referring to the Middle East exclusively as the “Arab world” and by questioning the identities of Jews, Assyrians, Chaldeans, and other distinctive, regional minorities. She wondered why these groups perceive themselves as separate from Arabs when the answer is readily apparent both in the distinctive histories of theses peoples and in their persecution at the hands of Arab Muslim majorities. The very term “Arab”—often used arbitrarily to describe anything Middle Eastern—is loaded with a perilous and extreme nationalism that has made ethnic minorities such as Mizrahi Jews and Assyrians victims of the majority.

Joseph questioned, and at times denounced, studies examining the status quo of women in the Middle East. She argued that the representation of Arab women as subjects is a “problematic category and necessary one,” and that there is serious fault with characterizations—particularly in Western research and media—of Arab women as the victims of patriarchy, culture, politics, and religion. Instead, Joseph contended, notions of self are changing and malleable.

Predictably for contemporary Middle East studies, Joseph paid tribute to Edward Said’s deeply flawed book Orientalism, which helps explain her rejection of any implied Western superiority regarding women’s rights. In asserting that Westerners shouldn’t assume women in the Middle East wish to imitate secular, Westernized women, she encapsulated the ideology widespread on college campuses: multiculturalism, a form of cultural relativism that denies the ability to judge non-Western cultures on their merits, and which, in practice, judges all non-Western cultures as superior. She made no reference to universal human rights or to the possible reasons for rising Arab immigration to secular European nations and to North America.

Joseph asserted that Arab women are the “most relationship-driven” of any with which she has worked. She described Americans, in contrast, as less “relationship-driven” and American women as having fewer expectations than their Arab counterparts. Joseph offered no factual evidence for either of these preposterous claims. Given the grave circumstances under which many Arab women live, one would think it is they who are forced to have fewer expectations and not, as Joseph contended, Western women.

Incredibly, Joseph theorized that Arab women want to be claimed by men, and therefore have no objection to being subjects of a patriarchal and theocratic society in which their individual rights are abridged. The audience, which appeared to consist mostly of Center for Near Eastern Studies and Women’s Studies faculty, nodded their heads in agreement with this troubling statement. In fact, those gathered reacted favorably to the lecture overall and asked no challenging questions of the speaker. Overwhelming (if understated) evidence of the systematic and institutionalized abuse of Middle Eastern women didn’t seem to factor into the equation.

In many regions of the Middle East, the basic standing of women and the attitude of men towards them are pre-modern. Were this not so, there would be no honor killings, female genital mutilation, child marriage, or legitimized wife-beating. Moreover, the West should consider the disturbing social implications for its societies as these barbaric customs are imported through Muslim immigration.

If I may end on a personal note: As a woman of Middle Eastern origin, the situation of women in the Middle East has always fascinated and troubled me. Although I come from a very traditional Middle Eastern family—albeit Jewish—the women in my family have always been empowered and independent. Therefore, I find it extremely difficult to come to terms with the theory that Middle Eastern women are a different breed who welcome abuse for some twisted concept of maintaining a “relationship-driven” society.

If one believes, as I do, in fundamental human rights, there are moral principles that define our basic freedoms. Middle Eastern women’s rights activists such as Shirin Ebadi and Ayaan Hirsi Ali do not excuse the misogynistic and theocratic elements in their native countries. Instead, they demand freedom, even in the face of their abusers and of Western apologists.

Unfortunately, Joseph’s lecture belongs in the latter category, demonstrating yet again that Middle Eastern women who seek intellectual and moral support from Western professors of Middle East studies will come away disappointed.

Reut Cohen is a journalist, researcher, and the publisher of ReutRCohen.com. She wrote this article for Campus Watch, a project of the Middle East Forum.

  • PolkaDot

    This seems very inspiring and promising site with some breakthrough approaches in IT development. I think we should be able to learn so many informative things from this site for our own benefit in learning an IT conceptual.online bidding

  • LondoJerika

    A good drama education and practicing website. We can share some common drama interests we have with the rest of members in this site and I think they will appreciate every contribution.jogos online

  • MerlinNanas

    Now, its time again women are not oppressed by men. I think women also have a role as important as men. There are not many women who worked in the past, but now as a woman grows could also have careers and are not inferior to men. Quiniela Nacional y Provincia

  • joedavids

    Hrmm that was weird, my comment got eaten. Anyway I wanted to say that it's nice to know that someone else also mentioned this as I had trouble finding the same info elsewhere. This was the first place that told me the answer. Thanks.
    time management

  • MauraLagie

    I have been seeing quite similar products being developed in many part of the world aiming to get the most attention from the potential market users. I think this is what has been quite interesting all these times about using the technology.http://reallycheaphealthinsurance.com

  • OpikaCerls

    There are many instances here locally where the selection process is not the way it is suppose to be done. There are so many collusion amongst parties involved for their own best interest.office furniture

  • Nida Janjua

    interestingly awesome writing, Your article is very useful. and i really appreciate it.. still there is one thing that in don’t understand you’re not even more popular than you are now.
    Jailbreak ios 5

  • Nida Janjua

    interestingly awesome writing, Your article is very useful. and i really appreciate it..
    Jailbreak ios 5

  • Maria

    THE BEACON OF APARTHEID HAS THE AUDACITY TO CHARGE MULTI-RACIAL ISRAEL'S BEAUTIFUL DEMOCRACY [THAT OFTEN GIVES PREFERENTIAL TREATMENT FOR ITS ARABS OVER JEWS] WITH THIS TERMINOLOGY?

    THE ARAB DECEPTIVE PROPAGANDA MACHINE THAT ACTS AS IF ARAB-ISLAMIC GENOCIDAL CAMPAIGN IS NOT OBVIOUS TO DETERMINE ISRAEL'S EXTRA SECURITY MEASURES [INCLUDING AN ANTI-TERROR / ANTI-MASSACRES WALL].

    As if we don't know the 'Arab oil lobby's power' over the UN, international organizations and some African officials to go along with the Arab propaganda.

    Even promoter of the apartheid-slur J. Carter admitted on CNN: "I recognize that Israel is a wonderful democracy with freedom of speech and equality of treatment under the law between Arab Israelis and Jewish Israelis." http://edition.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0612/12/acd.02

    Last but not least:

    Isn't it true that the anti-Jewish "apartheid" slur campaign is" 1) to demonize Jews and 2) to hide the real apartheid practice by the Arab-Islamic world?

  • Maria

    From anti-Jewish Apartheid:

    - The Arab racist apartheid against the Jews attempted genocide ever since the 1920s, (Like Mufti of "Palestine at his incited massacres, and Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood who called simply 'to kill Jews').
    - Chased out a Million Jews in the late 1940.
    - Has boycotted and demonized [every logical defensive action is branded "racist"] the Jewish democratic-free-equal-to-all state only because it's the "other". It is neither Muslim nor Arabs.
    - The Arab racist world continues to play with Arab-Palestinians (grandchildren of Arab immigrants) like ping-pong against Israel.

  • Maria

    * Maronites-Christians [Native Lebanese] suffer from both Arab ethnic racism and religious bigotry, like the massacres in the 1970s by local Muslims and by Palestinian/Syrian forces.
    * Assyrians, are/have been being persecuted both racially and religiously. Still very much marginalized in Iraq, for example.
    * Iran is not an Arab country but racism is huge against Kurds, Jews, Turkmens, etc.So is anti-non-Muslim bigotry against Christians, Bahai, Zoroastrians and other in the Islamic republic.
    * Turkey is also a Muslim non-Arab country and Kurds, Greeks, Armenians and other ethnicities have been through much suffering, genocide. Still there's great wide racism againt non-Turkish ethnic grpups. Turkey's policy in Cyprus has also been recognized as a real Apartheid by many. All non-Muslims are automatically branded as "foreingers" at the "moderate" Islamic supremacy of Turkey.
    * Al-Akhdam in Yemen.
    * Gypsies in Jordan.

  • Maria

    Arab apartheid / Muslim apartheid are the largest 'apartheid systems', that exist today. All non-Arabs and/or non-Muslims are second class citizens. Among minorities that feel the wrath of the bigoted Arab-Muslim world include:

    * Berbers (native N. Africans, before Arab invasion).
    * Copts (indigenous Egyptians suffer from both: Arab racism and Islamic bigotry).
    * Kurds (Examples include: [Saddam's] Iraq and Syria.
    * Blacks, in Arab lands or in Arab ruled Africa like the genocide in the Sudan and slavery in both Sudan and in Mauritania.
    * Asians, particularily in the Gulf Arab states. [Sex slaves or "plain" slaves).

  • SaniaHello

    The saving amount is huge if we can follow this tips. I think we need to do our best effort to ensure we can save as many energy as possible for our future generations. Although renewable energies are on the way, still we need to do something about our current.ssl

  • WelosDerk

    I am sure this italian version ice cream has more than plenty fans who happened to have a good concerns about weight and many things in their life. Gelato will surely makes you not to feel guilty.Breguet

  • Karen

    Genocidal Arab-Nazi leader: Ahmad Shukairy, ‘father’ of ‘Apartheid’ [lie] slander (1961) on the very victims of ‘Arab racism’
    http://freeisraelnow.blogspot.com/2011/06/genocidal-racist-arab-leader-ahmad.html

  • Nida Mansoor Malik

    Hey tons of thanks for this sharing, really helped me with my assignment. iPhone 5

  • JamuraNerk

    It is well expected for this application system to be able to used as one of the most dependant system application to avoid media counterfeiting actions by pirates. I know this is not going to end the problem permanently but at least we can reduce the riskSecond hand wedding dresses

  • KanyaDews

    I have seen many things in this world and this is something that I always like to see, any related medical articles for us to learn about many things. I am sure this is something we can do to improve ourself.Office Furniture

  • BingoJerk

    There are various information we can get from this website and at the same time this can also improve the level of awareness in our own people for them to be more than ready to improve their capability in holding up.ping online accounting

  • UtariJot

    He has been able to manifest the true horror characteristic from zombie which is coming towards the enemy of people using the modern background setting. I wish we can do so many things.Santa Ana DUI Attorney

  • http://blackbushcarauction.net/ blackbush car auction

    Would it be recommended that you minor in creative writing and major in biochemistry?

  • http://waterflosserreview.com water flosser

    In many regions of the Middle East, the basic standing of women and the attitude of men towards them are pre-modern. Hopefully this will soon become a thing of the past in this modern world.

  • Olive

    i donated once to CNES thinking what they did is pretty good and benefits the society.
    - Olive from christmas gifts store

  • Directpack

    nice information. Thank you for sharing it. Thanks Packers Movers

  • 99th

    Very useful information. Thank you for sharing it. Thanks 99th