The New York Times Finds Some Moderate Muslims

Pages: 1 2

Then comes Zaid Shakir, former Muslim chaplain at Yale University. He has said, according to Daniel Pipes, that “Muslims cannot accept the legitimacy of the existing American order, since it ‘is against the orders and ordainments of Allah.’ ‘[T]he orientation of the Quran,’ he adds, ‘pushes us in the exact opposite direction.’”

Others in the video include Jamal Badawi (who owes me a million dollars), an unindicted co-conspirator in the Holy Land Foundation Hamas terror funding case.

Hamza Yusuf also appears. He has made many antisemitic and anti-American statements, and most famously said two days before 9/11: “This country [America] unfortunately has a great, a great tribulation coming to it. And much of it is already here, yet people are too to illiterate to read the writing on the wall.”

And finally there is Yassir Qadhi, anointed by Ground Zero mega-mosque Imam Feisal Abdul Rauf as a “Muslim leader of tomorrow, who has said: “Hitler never intended to destroy the Jews… The Hoax of the Holocaust — I advise you to read this book, you’ll want to write this down — The Hoax of the Holocaust, a very good book. All of this is false propaganda…”

These are the spokesmen that the New York Times thinks are “rebutting” the “militants.” Pardon me if I decline the Kool-Aid.

Yet Daveed Gartenstein-Ross, director of the Center for the Study of Terrorist Radicalization at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies, seems to have imbibed it deeply. He said of the video: “It can be a powerful outlet. It is the kind of thing that, formatwise, is matching what’s being done by the jihadist groups.” The Times went on to say that Gartenstein-Ross “said that some of the scholars in the video were politically controversial but had credibility among many Muslims because they were not seen as ‘sell-outs.’ ‘Some would argue that they might be more effective than those perceived as more establishment figures.’”

“Politically controversial”? No kidding, really? This kind of analysis is on the level of saying that Osama bin Laden is a “polarizing” figure, but “more effective” than establishment types.

The Times article also quotes Edina Lekovic, director of policy and programming for the Muslim Public Affairs Council, the Islamic advocacy group responsible for the video. Edina Lekovic is the MPAC flack whom Steve Emerson caught lying on national television, denying she was editor of a Muslim student publication that praised Osama bin Laden as a great mujahid. Emerson produced copies of the rag showing Lekovic’s name on the masthead as editor on the very same page on which the praise for Osama appeared.

Score another for the keen analysts at the New York Times.

Pages: 1 2

  • Reason_For_Life

    These guys are about as moderate as Trotsky. But then, the Times thought Trotsky was OK too.

    Robert Spencer – Is this incompetence or malice? I haven't read the New York Times since high school when I figured out that it was biased. Back then, it was clearly malice.

    • PEm

      Compared to these guys, Trotsky was OK!

  • Elpi Nipni

    The Western Civilization is in grave danger because of our ignorance of Islam. Untill we realize that a moderate and Muslim are a contradiction in terms. We will fall and be subjugated to Islam for we have amongst us a fifth culumn other then Muslims, that fifth culumn is the LEFT. The Left has dominance over the Media and therefore we are being kept ignorance of the nature of that Ideology. Islam is a most supremacist Ideology who is the Mother of Nazism, Fascism and Communism. The usual mantra in the world treat Islam as a religion, there is nothing farther from truth about this concept. As long as we are trying to appease this headless monster we are going to fall before it.
    Even the September 11th disaster could not convince the Leftist Media who is the real enemy of the West and not only that, the left Media is enabling islam to destroy the west.
    A few Heroes like Robert Spencer, Andrew Bostom and Geert Wilders and some heavy caliber logical mind are not enough to stop the tide.We are doomed

    • Gil Sánchez-V.

      I couldn't agree more. I long ago quit the Jihad Watch forum (despite my admiration for the brave, bright people sustaining it through reason, knowledge and sense of purpose) because I couldn't find anyone agreeing with my proposal: It is an urgent task that we the true westerners get rid of all the traitors and Islam collaborators in our midst, disregrading their more-often-than-not obscure motives.
      If we could only accomplish that goal… getting rid of the medieval-minded islamist fifth columns will be like a breeze. Without that first basic sanitary step, all we can aspire to is to live trough the slow but sure demolition of our civilization from within.
      Cid Campeador

    • James


      God's word (The Bible) describes this time period. I would encourage you to read it. A great book that defines more clearly the Islamic Threat and how God deals with it is "God's War on Terror by Walid Shoebat." If we strive to be "Overcomer's" as described in the book of Revelation we may loose our lives; however, the overcomer is anything but "doomed." Read Revelation, perhaps you have eyes to see and ears to hear.

  • kafir4life

    What happened to suhaib's head? Has he been smackin' it into a wall or the ground or something? Could the repeated banging have caused any permenant brain damage (assuming there was anything to damage….it may have not been his turn with the muslim "brain").

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't sahaib one of them moon god worshippers? The moon god that was made up by the pedophilic so-called prophet mad mo? The same mad mo that shat the contents of the terror guide the koran from his anal orifice? The same terror guide that is followed by the adherants of the gutter cult of islam? That him?

  • sflbib

    Re: “This country [America] unfortunately has a great, a great tribulation coming to it.”

    I'm not a "blame-America-firster", but I think he has a point. If God doesn't do something soon to correct America's ways, He will owe Sodom and Gomorrah an apology.

    Re: "And much of it is already here, yet people are too to illiterate to read the writing on the wall."

    That's for sure. In all fairness though, the American people have been sold the bill of goods of tolerance über alles.

  • Ayatollah Ghilmeini

    Yes Hitler was just a German activist.

    Everyone of these men are dedicated to the doing whatever it takes to impose Sharia law world wide.

    The left thinks Islam is some form of Arabian Buddhism.

  • USMCSniper

    Amil Imani says: "Islam's Useful Idiot may even engage in willful misinformation and deception when it suits him. Terms such as 'Political Islam,' or 'Radical Islam,' for instance, are contributions of the Useful Idiot. These terms do not even exist in the native parlance of Islam, simply because they are redundant. Islam, by its very nature and according to its charter—the Quran—is a radical political movement. It is the Useful Idiot who sanitizes Islam and misguides the populace by saying that the 'real Islam' constitutes the main body of the religion; and, that this main body is non—political and moderate. But Islam is political to the core. In Islam the mosque and state are one and the same—the mosque is the state. This arrangement goes back to the days of Muhammad himself. Islam is also radical in the extreme. Even the 'moderate' Islam is radical in its beliefs as well as its deeds. Muslims believe that all non—Muslims, bar none, are hellfire bound and well—deserve being maltreated compared to believers."

  • scum

    Robert Spencer, If you would only quit the little boys club known as the Catholic Church, we might actually listen to you.

    • wasicu36

      Your screen name is absolutely appropriate

  • HanniBarca

    The Koran is an instructional manual for hate, intolerance and sexual obsession and its smile in your face, backstabbing adherents are cluelessly lighting the fuse of a megaton maelstrom.Israel has hundreds of nukes and accurate launch systems. The Plains of Megiddo will be the flash point of the war that Islam has brought upon itself and like their Nazi and Imperial Japanese predecessors the jihadis will see their "homelands" reduced to rubble and slag. Israel will achieve its destiny.

  • Dirk Lemmons

    What makes Islam, Islam? The Koran defines Islam not men making speeches. In my study of Islam ( I have found the Koran to be the smoking gun, covered with the blood soaked finger prints of Jihad murders.

  • Jenifer Watson3

    It is a tremendous article. It's content is superb and it's really well written. Superb job…. Embroidery Digitizing

  • Jenifer Watson3j

    What a great article, i just loved it and i loved to read it. Excellent thought author,i have bookmarked it.
    Embroidery Library

  • Barbi Rose

    Robert is right on. The way to defeat us is to use the media and play on our sympathies. To fight a war look to WW 1 or WW 2 you win. You defeat the enemy. If we fought Hitler and ToJo like we are fighting in Afganistan and Iraq we would be speaking either Japanese or German depending on what part of the previous United States of America we were in.