Great Scott!


Some of the most melancholy letters and e-mails that are sent to me are from people who lament that there is nothing they can do about the bad policies that they see ruining this country. They don’t have any media outlet for their opinions and the letters they send to their Congressmen are either ignored or are answered by form letters with weasel words. They feel powerless.

Sometimes I remind them that the whole political establishment — both Democrats and Republicans, as well as the mainstream media — were behind amnesty for illegal immigrants, until the public opinion polls showed that the voters were not buying it. If politicians can’t do anything else right, they can count votes.

It was the same story with the government’s health care takeover legislation. The Democrats have such huge majorities in both houses of Congress that they could literally lock the Republicans out of the room where they were deciding what to do, set arbitrary deadlines for votes, and cut off debate in the Senate. The mainstream media was on board with this bill too. To hear the talking heads on TV, you would think it was a done deal.

Then Scott Brown got elected to the “Kennedy seat” in the Senate, showing that that seat was not the inheritance of any dynasty to pass on. Moreover, it showed that the voters were already fed up with the Obama administration, even in liberal Massachusetts, as well as in Virginia and New Jersey. The backtracking on health care began immediately. Politicians can count votes. Once again, the public was not helpless.

One seat did not deprive the Democrats of big majorities in Congress. But one seat was the difference between being able to shut off debate in the Senate and having to allow debate on what was in this massive legislation. From day one it was clear that concealing what was in this bill was the key to getting it passed.

That is why there had to be arbitrary deadlines— first to get it passed before the August 2009 recess, then before Labor Day, then before the Christmas recess.

The President could wait months before deciding to give a general the troops he asked for to fight the war in Afghanistan but there was never to be enough time for the health care bill to be exposed in the light of day to the usual Congressional hearings and debate.

Moreover, despite all the haste, the health care program would not actually go into effect until after the 2012 presidential election. In other words, the public was not supposed to find out whether the government’s takeover of medical care actually made things better or worse until after it was too late.

Although even the members of Congress who voted on this massive legislation did not have time to read its thousands of pages, just the way it was being rushed through in the dark should have told us all we needed to know. For many voters, that turned out to be enough.

Even after Scott Brown came out of nowhere to make a stunning upset election victory, there were still some cute political tricks that could have been pulled to save the health care bill. But enough Democrats saw the handwriting on the wall that they were not going to risk their own re-election to save this bill that Barack Obama has been hell-bent to pass, even when polls showed repeatedly that the public didn’t want it.

President Obama’s desire to do something “historic” by succeeding, where previous presidents had failed, was perfectly consistent for a man consumed with his own ego satisfaction, rather than the welfare of the country or even of his own political party.

As for the public, it doesn’t matter if your Congressman answers your letter with a form letter, or doesn’t answer at all. What matters is that you let him know what you are for or against and, when enough people do that— whether in letters, in polls or in an election, politicians get the message, because they know their jobs depend on it.

As for what is likely to happen to health care, neither the bill passed by the House of Representatives nor the Senate bill can be expected to be enacted into law. Meanwhile, Obama’s reaction to his political setback has been to respond rhetorically and to call on the political operatives who helped engineer his successful election campaign in 2008. But the public did not know him then, and his rhetoric may not fool them again, now that they do.

  • Gabrielle

    I must admit that I had given up writing to my representatives in the House and Senate, because I knew 2 out of 3 were not listening to me. Yes, I was being put off by the nonresponses and form letters. I regarded my efforts as a waste of my time. I am now going to rethink my retreat. You are so right, Dr. Sowell, we all must persevere in making our positions known, even if our elected senators and representatives are not interested or object to them.

    • John C. Davidson

      We all have found personal letters to our representatives have been ignored. Now we must make our concerns public, those they cannot ignore. Get involved locally as well as continuing to join in discussions with others whose opinions are not paid for by special interest groups.

      Do not sell your soul to socialism for the only winners are the very idiots who want to maintain their power over us all.

      There are a lot of good people out there and Dr. Sowell heads the list.

  • johncarens

    It is stunning to me how many people have missed the subtext of Brown's victory, and Mr. Sowell touched on it lightly: The only reason this election mattered (and mattered to the stunning degree it did) was because it thwarted the clearly tyrannical intentions of Congress to frog-march this legislation through without open debate, or even the ability of Americans to comment on it as a completed form of legislation. Remember, there still is no "Health Care Bill".

    This is Burning-Down-The-Reichstag stuff. Most Americans are sophisticated enough to catch a whiff of the odor of authoritarianism of the process in which this bill was fashioned, which was as terrifying to them as the proposed law itself.

    The fact there there has been no outrage from our "Fourth Estate" about this (and, in fact, has belittled and impugned the crusty citizens that spent their own money and resources to attend "Town Hall" meetings or "Tea Parties which emphasized it), and that they allowed the congress to meet behind locked, closed doors tells us all we need to know about both the lack of seriousness of our media, and how close we are to living in a "soft tyranny".

    We've dodged a bullet. Thank God for Massachusetts. Honestly.