Pakistan and the Arab Spring

Pages: 1 2

Third, injunctions or fatwas are delivered by clerics based upon their interpretation of Sharia in the broadly defined area of the “code of conduct” for Muslims. For instance, fatwas ranging from prohibiting Muslim girls from receiving modern education or banning the use of polio vaccines, to favoring (Sharia-compliant) Islamic banking have been delivered in Pakistan by clerics.

The significantly lower output in Pakistan (compared to that of India) – in terms of the number of book titles published or the number of doctorates awarded, even after adjusting for the population ratios  –  may be attributed to the socio-economic influence of Sharia. In the years 2004 and 2007, 1,072 new titles and 432 doctorates were released and awarded in Pakistan, respectively. Yet even when scaled to India’s population, Pakistan has managed to produce just about 8,000 book titles and 3,000 doctorates, compared to India’s 82,537 titles and 14,000 doctorates.

A nation’s per capita gross domestic product (GDP) is a useful (lagging) indicator of the impact of a government’s socio-economic policies implemented under the influence of regressive ideologies such as Sharia. While Pakistan’s per capita GDP rose slightly from $2,000 to $2,400 from 1999 to 2009, India’s per capita GDP nearly doubled from $1,800 to $3,400 during the same period.

In sum, as observed in Pakistan, the continued emphasis on Sharia in a Muslim community as a divine code of conduct eventually leads to an entrenched religiosity, regressive outlook, socio-economic stagnation and violent radicalism directed at non-Muslims as well as internal conflicts. In contrast, India’s embrace of modernity, as evidenced in part by its secular and democratic constitution has led to a continued socio-economic development and resulted in a moderate outlook.

As evidenced in Pakistan, it appears that popular support for Sharia is a necessary condition for the large scale formation of jihadist groups. Conversely, reduced enthusiasm for Sharia relates to the same for armed jihad. For instance, the inability of al-Qaeda to sustain itself in Iraq even in the chaotic aftermath of the American intervention can be construed as in part due to a lack of favorable conditions for Sharia aided by decades of Saddam Hussein’s Sharia-limiting policies.

A long-running social experiment called Pakistan has taught us the perils of advancing Sharia under any form of governing. Supporting Islamists in Arab nations for whom a core vision is Sharia, it appears, will likely ensure the formation of many Arab-versions of Pakistan.

That would be one too many failed experiments.

Freedom Center pamphlets now available on Kindle: Click here.

Pages: 1 2

  • C"H"Martel

    My book, "Satan's Trinity: Hitler, Stalin & Muhammad, is available at For the first time in history "HSM" appear together on a book cover. The idea behind the book is to make headway against the ludicrous idea that Muhammad should be conjoined with any religious leader/founder. This book uses the specific names of Hitler and Stalin to efficiently identify the nature of Muhammad and by extension Islam. It compares the personalities and approach of each man to such categories as; war, peace, sex, torture, slavery, women, their respective childhoods and deaths, the critical affects of geography and timing, each man’s anti-social and narcissistic personalities.

  • 080

    The trouble with the Arab Spring is that they left out the part about where people get to eat.

  • WilliamJamesWard

    War is all that will stop Islam from moving and growing into the free world and
    bringing it's dark barbarism full of pain and suffering into our future. At some
    point tolerance which is cowardly suicide will have to end as there are enough
    sane people to desire to continue the American heritage and culture. I may be
    wrong and the creep may move forward to domination and damnation of all we
    have loved and held sacred. Our politicans today are traitors to the past, present
    and future. We are waiting on the man with the voice, strength of character,
    the will and vision to turn the tide and call it, showtime……………..William

  • LindaRivera

    Persecution of non-Muslims – Hindus, Christians and Sikhs in Pakistan and Bangladesh is so severe that all of the non-Muslims in these countries need to be rescued out. Unfortunately, Western nations ignore the terrible suffering of non-Muslims in Muslim countries and instead of rescuing non-Muslims, they take in huge numbers of Muslims.

    Many millions of Islam's foot soldiers colonize our countries. In Israel, India, Europe and the UK there are many no-go Muslim areas where it is too dangerous for non-Muslims to enter. In some Muslim areas of Europe, the hate for non-Muslims is so fierce that ambulances require a police escort.

  • Jaladhi

    Sharia is a set of seventh century stone age barbaric social laws. Following sharia simply drags Muslims back to the stone age of Mo/allah preventing any kind of progress. Pakistan is an example of recent history but go hundreds of years back and you will find the same backwardness in Muslim societies as shown by Pakistan!!.