Just What Is a “Green” Job?

Pages: 1 2

President Obama promised three years ago that by the end of the decade America would have 5 million green jobs. We have come up a bit short. Instead, at least 14 million potential workers are jobless.

But what is a “green” job any way? To find out, start with an exchange between Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa), ranking member of the Budget and Finance Committee, and the Department of Labor.

In a letter to Labor Secretary Hilda Solis, Sept. 23, 2010, Grassley wrote:

“Since February 2009, the Department has awarded approximately $490 million in Stimulus funding designed for ‘green job’ training. Yet the Department, according to its own documents, is still only ‘working to develop a definition for green sectors and jobs.’”

Earlier—in June 2010–Grassley had written Secretary Solis noting that he had opposed the American Recovery Act (the stimulus) because it was

“loaded with spending to satisfy special interests…However, it has come to my attention that the DOL (Department of Labor) is just now attempting to define what a ‘green job’ is….more than a year after the Recovery Act was signed into law and after millions of dollars in funding have already been distributed for green jobs….I would like to understand what criteria the DOL used to give out millions of taxpayer dollars prior to the definition being established.”

DOL Assistant Secretary Jane Oates responded to Grassley, saying that the stimulus act authorized DOL to award $740 million for worker training and placement, with $500 million for research, labor exchange and job training projects to “prepare workers for careers in energy efficiency and renewable energy.” Cited were inexact definitions of green jobs existing at the time, including a Department-supported research paper called “Greening of the World of Work.” It included Indian and Native American workforce development and a database of occupational requirements and worker attributes. In other words, no specific definition.

She also said the Bureau of Labor Statistics was researching other countries and states for their definitions of green jobs. This included, she said, identifying organizations that use environmentally-friendly production.

But the BLS definition “is solely for statistical purposes and is not applicable to the grants. The definition of green jobs that results from the BLS will not affect the funding of the grants.”

Maybe some day, the DOL will find a definition that it likes.

The White House Middle Class Task Force, headed by Joe Biden, has come up with a number of definitions:

Green jobs have the potential to be quality, family-sustaining jobs that also help improve our environment. They are largely domestic jobs that can’t be off-shored. They tend to pay more than other jobs, even controlling for worker characteristics. Moreover, green jobs are an outgrowth of a larger movement to reform the way we create and use energy in both this country and the rest of the world.

They represent a growth sector, and one that offers the dual promise of providing good jobs while meeting the environmental challenge to reduce our dependence on finite fossil fuels that generate harmful carbon emission….Because definitions of green jobs are so broad at this point in time, it is impossible to generate a reliable count of how many green jobs there are in America today. We can, however, identify jobs in industries and occupations that are likely to be green jobs.

Green jobs are good jobs: they pay more, by 10 to 20 percent, depending on the definition, than other jobs. Green jobs are more likely to be union jobs than other jobs….

“There is no official or even widely-accepted definition of what constitutes a green job,” Biden’s report said.

Meanwhile the DOL’s Office of Inspector General conducted an audit of the $500 million for job training to prepare workers for green jobs, or “careers in energy efficiency and renewable energy.”

Pages: 1 2

  • Chezwick_mac

    What is a green job?

    A green job is like Big Foot, the Loch Ness monster, or a GENUINE Muslim reformer….nothing but a figment of our fertile imaginations.

  • Ken

    Don't forget the Yeti, mac!! LOL

  • velmaellis

    So how can you get in on this expansion of the clean, mean and "green" industries? By getting a "green" job that pays handsomely, of course you need a degree from universities like "High Speed Universities".

    • wsk

      First you must go to an Internet only college. Once you "graduate", then you join a union. Then the mney comes pouring in by the bucketload.

  • kafir4life

    The President's Fast & Furious is considered a "green" program. Here's how it works.
    1.) The President earns commissions on each gun sold. Puts "green" in his coffers.
    2.) Each time an Obama brand gun is used (as in the case of the border patrol agent), the carbon footprint of the individual(s) on the open end of the transaction is removed from the planet. The younger the open end of the transaction is when the transaction occurs, the larger the positive effect on the planet.

    In 458 days, this national nightmare will come to a close.

  • Rifleman

    I saw somewhere this week that by their own estimates, the executive branch's green jobs training program is 10% effective. If it was a weapons program they would have eliminated it by now.

  • StephenD

    Actually, working at a gas station can be considered a "Green Job" as can organic farmers who re-use dung, or a ditch digger that digs a trench to re-use run off storm water for irrigation. Essentially anything that touches on energy use can narrowly fit the definition of a "green job."
    So, where is the money set aside for training? What training has it been spent on?
    Not to worry, Joe Bidden is busy yelling about the money that police need and how the evil Republicans are trying to deny them. A simple solution is to consider that the police clean the crap from the streets and then it gets recycled back out. That could be considered a green job! Hey, it's as a good a definition as the Feds have now!