The Death of Illusions

Pages: 1 2

In other words, we have been sold out.  The West has sold — betrayed altogether — that small part of the Russian population that has upheld the values of freedom and was ready to walk barefoot upholding liberty through snow and perennial ice.  It was ready to climb every mountain and every peak. And the selling out was done in a manner that has not happened for a very long time. To be truthful, I had not expected this from President Obama.

And if now they will ratify the agreement of the START treaty, this will be understood as a gift to Russia, as an agreement with every detail of its policy. There will be no more “interference” in our internal concentration camp.  And as there sat in prison the Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo, this year’s Nobel Peace Prize winner, in this manner he will continue sitting. He is to be imprisoned for 10 more years, and it is very possible that he will not come out alive and will never see that Nobel Prize.

Nobody defends political prisoners. Nobody defends Khodarkovsky, and this could have been done very easily and quickly.  All that is necessary is for the members of the G8 to raise their voices in a decisive manner.  Were this to be done, the case of YUKOS would have been dissipated like a horrible dream. But no — the members have permitted this trial, and this public auto de fé, this public torment, continues on and on.

I actually think that there is a simple reason why Judge Danilkin was told to postpone the reading of the sentence.  It was decided to wait for the most fiery Western journalists to take their Christmas vacation — December 25th is the world’s Christmas — and then in the rush and business of the season (the season’s meaning is nothing to them) with Putin’s four hour speech on TV in the background, they were made to read such a shameful judgment that all of us had no choice but to be silently aghast.  And we will be absolutely ashamed, and we will not be able to do anything, not even to sit next to the sentenced men, as long ago we, dissidents, used to sit down.  And it is our shame that we must watch this nightmare.

But more than that. By the New Year’s celebration, while the Russian salad Olivie was being served, it became clear that Putin had succeeded in the education of the young and that his and Surkov’s exercises with “nashists” (Russian nationalists), with local young crowds, with “Young Russia” had great results; the young can proudly display their might, trampling the portraits of the opposition leaders on the city square.  We have educated our own well-trained fascist youth. These fanatical boys, fed and trained by the Kremlin, were used in pillaging the offices of the opposition, and these boys raise their fascist salute near the walls of Kremlin.  And these boys exclaim “Russia for the Russians”. . . .

In other words, without leaving Sovok, without giving up our Soviet training, we have arrived at the neo-fascist state….

I think that the hopes that Russian political leaders would want some change, that they would listen to the wise words of no longer living Gaidar, that if they want to survive, they need to protect democracy (so we would not turn into Pakistan, or into the Third World, or even fourth or fifth) — these hopes have no place in our lives any more.  I think the war is announced, there is no pretense and no illusions about the possibilities of working with this ruling elite, of looking for round-table discussions, mutual organizations, mutual sofas and committees etc. — these illusions have no place any more. This is a year when all illusions should die.

Valeria Novodvorskaya is one of the leaders of the party Democratic Union of Russia.  In 1969, she was arrested for the first time. She was imprisoned at a special psychiatric hospital (a general practice of punishing dissidents). She described her experiences there in her book Beyond Despair. After her release, she studied evenings at the Department of Foreign Languages of the Moscow Regional Teacher’s College. Since 1972, she issued and distributed samizdat. In 1988, she was among those who formed the party Democratic Union. She was arrested on a charge of slogans to a coup d’etat in May 1991 and released in August 1991. In 1993, she was in the pre-election bloc of the Party of Economic Liberty.

Pages: 1 2

  • Alexander Gofen

    Valeria Novodvorskaya is a bright lady indeed (whom I was privileged even to meet once personally). She understands the realities of Russia perfectly well, yet what goes about America and the West she doesn't. Her confession

    "Obama was our hope"

    tells it all. She continuous:

    "… we have been sold out. The West has sold – betrayed altogether – that small part of the Russian population that has upheld the values of freedom…"

    However that was exactly what the West has been doing all the time since the Bolsheviks took the power! And the Manchurian (better to say Bilderberg's) "president" Obama is the culmination of those very policies of betrayal by the West, and of the West itself. Yet she is so correct saying

    "A new age has begun, and the sun will not rise"

    • Mira Chakalova

      The English translation is inaccurate in suggesting that Valeria Novodvorskaya was once among those who focused their hopes on Obama. She says:

      „Обама на которого все так надеялись“

      which means "Obama who everyone had such high hopes for" rather than "Obama was our hope". I think you would agree that the offered translation distorts the meaning. The fact that non-Russian speakers only have access to the written version erodes things further as it fails to convey a subtle element of sarcasm in her words, which is key.

      Having said that, I remain grateful to the people who have popularised this interview by translating it into English. The main points that Valeria Novodvorskaya makes are clear and deserve attention.

  • davarino

    America fights for freedom at the same time forces within undermine that struggle. We need to purge our intelligence, and military agencies.

    • stephencuz

      It would fail if it stopped there. We would have to purge academia as well, beginning with the primary education of our youth who are essentially indoctrinated to hold in contempt our capitalist way of life. They are taught to see morals as having a base no more solid than the projection of the present where those with voice tell them what is just and good. When definitions can change so readily, we all become subject to populist opinion rather than moral absolutes. This is a more dire threat in its consequence to my mind than a recognizable push toward socialism.

      • MontanaRob

        I think it needs to begin with academia now, a continuation of the purge in DC, and yes, a careful cleansing of the military and intelligence communities. A strict pledge to remain loyal to the Constitution and traditional American values must be at the core, with the penalties for failing to uphold that pledge to be quickly and severely dealt with., no excuses, no exceptions!

  • Steve Chavez

    In the 1980's, Obama, many members of Congress, employees in every government department, university professors and their students who then became public school teachers, were followers of Communist Party USA fronts funded and directed by the Soviet KGB! "The Followers of the 80's KGB are now the leaders of the U.S.A. today!" They are legitimizing "Socialism" which is just a PC term and part of this plan is to show a better face of Communism by focusing on Vladimir Putin as being "cool." He was on Larry King, videos of him playing piano and singing, judo, horseback riding, shirtless, four hour call in with millions of questions, and all to brainwash the world, but mostly the USA, to show that "Socialism" isn't that bad.Democrat Party!

  • Steve Chavez

    Obama, Hillary, and many of their employees under them, loved the Soviet Union more than their own country! Many of them praise the likes of Mao, Minh, and Castro. Hillary smiling with Chavez but she's the most popular again even though she was embarassed by Bill's adultery and she had no honor to leave, only to retain power and the perks, while brave women leave with nothing? If you go to CPUSA.ORG OR PWW.ORG you will see the similarities with the Democrat Party!

  • USMCSniper

    She writes:
    "Obama was our hope, for we thought that he was a pupil of Salinger and would be saving us, lost children, in the rye over the abyss. We thought he would protect us from lies and would not let us fall — and that there would be an end of double-faced diplomacy " “The danger to America is not Barack Obama but a citizenry capable of entrusting a man like him with the Presidency. It will be far easier to limit and undo the follies of an Obama presidency than to restore the necessary common sense and good judgment to a depraved electorate willing to have such a man for their president. The problem is much deeper and far more serious than Mr. Obama, who is a mere symptom of what ails America . Blaming the prince of the fools should not blind anyone to the vast confederacy of fools that made him their prince. The Republic can survive a Barack Obama, who is, after all, merely a fool. It is less likely to survive a multitude of fools such as those who made him their president.”

  • Mike in VA

    It's sad to read about foreigners' misplaced faith in Barack Obama, but like so many Americans who could not or would not see past that poseur's empty rhetoric, they ultimately have themselves to blame – not all of us were fooled by this charlatan and the praise heaped upon him by the starry-eyed votaries of his cult of personality. They held him up to the heavens, projecting their own hopes and visions upon him, and now that their Icarus has crashed to earth, they are sorely disappointed and disillusioned. Their Redeemer, their Deliverer has failed them. They bought into the soaring rhetoric, thinking that his by lofty words and charisma alone, he could magically change the hearts and minds of thugs like Vladimir Putin and Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. Had they stopped singing his praises long enough to actually listen to the man, they would have discovered what many of us knew a long time ago.

    I should feel sorry for these people, but their disillusionment is a direct product of their own irrationality. They helped create the Myth, they helped raise their Hero to the pinnacle of power – they have no one to blame but themselves. To compound their error, when they were warned, they refused to listen, choosing to withdraw into the comfort of their delusional Rapture.

    So, no, I don't feel sorry for these fools. Obama did not betray them – nothing about the man has changed – they betrayed themselves and all of us along with them. Let them weep over their own folly, but I won't weep over them. Their tears and lamentations inspire contempt, not pity.

    • Alexander Gofen

      It is true what you wrote, yet it is not about Valeria Novodvorskaya. In no way is she associated with "starry-eyed votaries "

      • Jamie Glazov

        Thanks Alexander.

      • Mike in VA

        Duly noted, Alexander, and thank you for pointing that out.

    • 2maxpower

      ….no obama didn't betray them. they did indeed betray themselves. obama was well known to anyone capable of a modicum of critical thought.

      the education system has corrupted fully half the population of north america. that and people are becoming lazy expecting/wishing for some windfall.

      no magic here people. just a lot of personal betrayal.

  • ajag23

    It is sad how a majority of Americans would vote for a president who had arrogantly declared to fundamentally transform America, and to introduce policies that would make electricity rates sky-rocket. For those who knew the truth about Obama's lifelong immersion in far left socialist activities, these were shocking and frightening statements, and his election meant that America had joyfully welcomed its own October revolution presided over by a new Lenin made appealing by his personality and a nice family. Sadly, most people were duped and deceived by the useful idiots in the media and academia, but are now being awakened by the truth that is slowly emanating. There is hope that the wait for change will be much shorter than seventy years which should be encouraging to Russian dissidents like Valeria Novodnoskaya.

    • Alexander Gofen

      Well said!

      The analogy with Lenin's coup in 1917 is even stronger. Notwithstanding the votes of the duped 67 millions, the pompous campaigning and affirmation of a blatantly illegitimate candidate could happen only under the criminal confederacy of the all government structures…

  • Ghostwriter

    Let's be honest here. Obama is operating under the illusion that we can talk to people like Putin,A-jad,Chavez,etc,that they'll be nicer to us and leave us alone. Unfortunately,he's still living with those illusions and it will be to our peril.


    Ohh valeria … you are talking about Obama and the West betraying the wide-eyed Eastern hopefuls, which is bad enough, but consider this: Obama and the western Left are betraying the West itself. I am not sure where you live (in the West or in the East), but you have no idea what the Communist/Fascist totalitarian 'philosophy' exported from, and nurtured by, the Soviet east has done to those of us who were fortunate enough to be born and raised in the West (USA, in particular), where individual freedom and liberty reigned. NOT ANY LONGER. The left has all but finished its take over of America (and europe was lost almost half a century ago). You are talking about sinking and sun never shining upon the hopes you tied to the West? We are talking about sinking and sub never shining on the entire humanity—including the West. Lament if you must. (And we will, for we must, too.) But at least try to look at the larger picture. It is not just your ex-soviet populous hopes that are being murdered. It is the entire humanity that is on the slaughter block, and i am ashamed to report that it is our WESTERN doofuses ('dopes') that let it happen. If you are REALLY concerned, help us FIGHT this monster that you know all too well, and our dummy americans can't even begin to conceive of, let alone fight.

    • Mira Chakalova

      SECREV, your frustration is palpable and you have every reason to be aggravated by the direction the West has taken. Your emotional outburst is therefore perfectly understandable, however, it is not right to address your grievances to Valeria Novodvorskaya. She is very much on top of the “larger picture” and by being politically active and outspoken, she is doing everything she could possibly do from within Russia to “fight the monster”.

      Thanks to Alexander Gofen for his earlier comment clarifying Novodvorskaya’s position (response to Mike VA above).