Islam’s Universal Economic Failure

Daniel Greenfield, a Shillman Journalism Fellow at the Freedom Center, is a New York writer focusing on radical Islam. He is completing a book on the international challenges America faces in the 21st century.


Pages: 1 2

If Romney accomplished nothing else during his Israeli visit, he did manage to offend every single Palestinian Arab terrorist group, all of whom, the Palestinian Authority, Hamas, Islamic Jihad, the PFLP and the DFLP, issued press releases denouncing him. American media outlets have been denouncing him for saying that the GDP Per Capita differences between Israel and the Palestinian Authority represent a contrast in values.

The official media narrative is that these differences are the results of oppression, checkpoints and blockades. But then why does the IMF put Israel’s GDP Per Capita well ahead of the oil-rich kingdom of Saudi Arabia?

Saudi Arabia has no Israeli checkpoints, no Israeli soldiers or planes flying overhead. It has wealth literally pouring out of the ground with a fifth of the world’s petroleum reserves. And yet the IMF puts it 13 places behind Israel and the World Bank puts it 8 places behind Israel. The only Muslim countries with a better GDP Per Capita than Israel are small monarchies drowning in oil.

The non-oil Muslim countries who are closest to Israel are Malaysia and Lebanon, 32 and 33 places behind Israel. Both countries also have sizable non-Muslim populations. Muslims make up only 50 percent of Lebanon and only 60 percent of Malaysia. No Muslim country without oil has a better GDP Per Capita than a Muslim country with sizable Christian or Buddhist minorities.

What Romney didn’t mention, but should have, is that the Palestinian Authority dealt yet another blow to its economy when it drove out the Christian population. Christians in the territories have traditionally made the best businessmen and the capital of the Palestinian Authority was actually started by Jordanian Christian refugees escaping Muslim persecution.

Israel has 1.2 Muslims inside the Green Line who account for 52 percent of its social benefits. Israel’s national unemployment rate is 5.6 percent. The Arab unemployment rate is 27 percent. Only 59 percent of Muslim men and only 19 percent of Muslim women are officially part of the workforce.  That’s compared to 56 percent of Jewish women and 52 percent of Christian women.

The average Israeli family has double the monthly income of the average Arab family. Half the Arab sector officially lives in poverty. The Israeli Jewish GDP is nearly three times higher than the Arab-Israeli GDP.

This could be blamed on the usual scapegoat of racism, but the Israeli Arab GDP of $6,750 is actually better than the $5,900 GDP in neighboring Jordan, the $6,540 GDP in Egypt and the $5,041 GDP in Syria. This is the same range in which most non-oil Arab Muslim states are grouped and it is clear that there is no escaping it without a big petroleum reserve. Or like Lebanon with its $15,523 GDP, a whole lot of Christians to actually work for a living.

Again culture is the determinant. Israel within the Green Line only has about 150,000 Christians and about as many Druze, and both groups perform better economically. Christian Arabs have a higher employment rate and a better rate of higher education than Muslims.

Apart from that official 1.2 million, Israel is also responsible for the 4 million in the Palestinian Authority (some of whom overlap with that 1.2 million and some of whom are imaginary and exist only to collect benefits from international agencies) who are still Israel’s responsibility, according to them and to the world, even though they also continue insisting that they want their own state.

The reason why the GDP in Palestinian areas is so terrible is because its inhabitants live in a giant welfare state. Palestinian Arabs were already receiving 725 dollars in per capita assistance. They don’t need an economy because the United States and the European Union are their economy. They don’t need a state because the UNRWA is their state.

It’s easy to admire Israel for what it has accomplished, but it stands out so much because of the region it’s in. Singapore and Hong Kong are less remarkable because they are in a region where countries don’t just give up and wait around for foreigners to come and find oil on their land. In Asia, countries make things happen for themselves. In the Middle East, if you’re not Jewish or Christian and you don’t have oil, then you have economic problems.

But let’s leave the Middle East and head over to Asia. India and Pakistan are divided by a GDP Per Capita difference of almost a thousand dollars. India is naturally in the lead. Within India, Muslims are at the bottom of the economic ladder. Their per capita GDP is lower, their literacy rate is lower and they perform worse than Hindus. And yet the average Indian Muslim annual income at 513 dollars is still higher than the average annual income in Pakistan at 420 dollars. This remains consistent with the higher Arab-Israeli income and lower Jordanian Arab income model meaning that Muslims in non-Muslim countries will earn less than the majority, but more than they would in a majority Muslim country.

Pages: 1 2

  • madhu

    Interesting article….yet I feel no sympathy because their reasons for such existence is nothing but the conversion of all non muslims to islam. If they have such unemployment and drop out numbers in the western countries then why are they there?

    I would like you to read a book. What muslims believe by John fowler. This was an interview on BBC with a learned muslim. There he actually speaks of converting UK into a muslim state. It is very interesting. I have read it over and over again and am angry at the world for allowing such savages to propagate in western society. Islam has already ruined the east.

    As far as Pakistan and Bangladesh are concerned, I was given the impression that USA is funding them to attack India again and again and how can you compare their unemployment to that of India when Bangladeshis have infiltraded, in millions, in India and the population of India is much greater than that of Pakistan and Bangladesh.

    Your kind of article amuses me because there is no way you can compare countries that are not at par with each other. EU is a great example of this.

    As far as Somalia is concerned, this is a trick of muslims. They have been told to take over the world for Allah and therefore they are creating internal strife so that they can spread all over the world and propagate islam. That is why they do not mind their poor condition. The west is a totally immoral society as per their teachings..They definitely have a bigger goal in mind. You have to study INdia for this.

    The world is still naive. Does not wish to accept the truth. Somalis have two or more wives and almost 20 children from one man. Funny eh?

    No. you are stupid. They are smart. They know exactly what they are going to do with the world. It is you who needs to grow up.

  • LiberateYourMind

    Just because you don't like the information in this article does not make it "disgusting, racist and poorly researched." It is obviously well researched because the economic data presented is not in dispute. It is not racist because race was not even mentioned. This article is about the effect of religion (not race) upon economic activity.
    And the Koran does NOT encourage a hard work ethic. In fact, the Koran promises Muslims that they will live comfortably if they have faith in Allah. For example: “And whosoever fears God, to him will He grant a prosperous issue, and will provide for him whence he reckoned not upon it.” Koran 65:2. AND: “He (Allah) will send down upon you the very heavens in plenteous rains; and he will increase you in wealth and in children, and will give you gardens and watercourses.” Koran 71:10, 11.

  • Omar K Cheema

    isreal is just as small as the small monarchies drowning in oil.
    israel is also drowning , not in oil, but billion of dollars of US aid.