Bringing the War on Jerusalem to American Universities

Pages: 1 2

It should be noted that Barghouti had expounded on a similar theme recently when he addressed the annual conference meeting of J Street, the self-described “pro Israel” and “pro peace” political action committee, which in reality is an anti-Israel propaganda outlet funded by the likes of radical billionaire George Soros.

Barghouti told the J Street attendees that “Some people might not like the word apartheid…We [Palestinians] actually live in that system…I cannot describe to you the level of [Israeli] violations of human rights.”

However, the fact that the OTI would list Mustafa Barghouti as an “institutional supporter” of the organization should engender little surprise given the wealth of other nefarious speakers involved with the group, as well as its heavy promotion of the demonize of Israel.

To achieve its goal of indoctrinating naive college students, the OTI provides its Christian, Jewish and Muslim student members trips to Israel and surrounding territories and a purportedly “balanced” speakers forum, so that they may experience “dialogue.” In reality, by putting wildly unacceptable views about Israel on par with mainstream views, the program legitimates the rhetoric of professional Israel-bashers like Barghouti, whom the program effectively deems a purveyor of an acceptable alternative point of view.

The GMJ will be followed by an upcoming anti-Israel event organized by Mazin Qumsiyeh, another notorious friend of the OTI. Qumsiyeh, who had organized the failed July 2011 “Flytilla,” an effort to fly several hundred high-profile militant activists into the West Bank in order to provoke a confrontation with the IDF, is reportedly organizing another Flytilla for mid-April.

Student participants in the OTI have even met with members of the terrorist organization Hamas. In 2009, a UC Irvine student trip to Israel sponsored by OTI included a meeting with Aziz Duwaik, a top Hamas leader. Students were instructed to cover up the meeting, and no investigation was conducted by UC Irvine. It should be noted that Aziz Duwaik was later arrested in January 2012 by the IDF on suspicion of terrorist activity.

In addition to meeting with Hamas, OTI students have met with representatives from other groups, including Sabeel, a leader in the anti-Israel church divestment campaign, and the Alternative Information Center (AIC), which has compared Israeli military and political figures to Nazis. Many of these OTI associates were also involved with the GMJ and the flytilla.

Unfortunately, the work of the OTI has been made possible by the financial support of Jewish organizations like the Jewish Federation of Orange County, and has enjoyed friendly relations with Hillel, the Jewish student organization. It continues to grow and expand to more universities every year. Thus, their network and alliances are very clear.

Organizations such as Ha-Emet have notified the Jewish Federation of Orange County of the concerns about the Olive Tree Initiative. However, it has yet to repudiate its association with this organization and has so far declined to sign the Fogel Pledge, a document meant to ensure federation funding does not go toward any activities that promote BDS or the demonization of Israel. With associates such as Barghouti, Qumsiyeh and Duwaik in their midst, the OTI certainly falls under this rubric.

Freedom Center pamphlets now available on Kindle: Click here.

Pages: 1 2

  • Schlomotion

    The admissions in this article are breathtaking. You admit that the Hamas-Fatah coalition, and subsequently any type of democratic coalition in Palestine is a horror to you. You admit that while Zionist groups have college-based panel discussions to promote Israel all the time, no such Palestinian groups should be allowed to exist. You admit that you think college students cannot think for themselves and that sponsored trips to Israel (just like Birthright Israel does) could only mesmerize their minds and bribe them to be anti-Israel. Is this because the PLO isn't giving them extacy and throwing them in a waterfall and taking them clubbing, but rather showing them the bantustans and the machine gun parapets? You admit that you are trying to take away these people's right to speak. You admit that you are targeting specific individuals and stalking them across the country to politically disenfranchise them. You are harassing organizations and trying to force them to repudiate people who have a different agenda from yourself. Your ire includes Palestinians, Christians, Muslims, and a vast quantity of Jews. Why should people listen to you and not them?

    • Bartimaeus

      It is a matter of truth and error. The truth shall set you free, but error and lies, presented as truth, is the road to destruction… If a group of Palestinian supporters was formed to actually exam the facts of history and rationally look for ways to create peace that would be fine, but this is not the case. What good is teaching that refuses to look at Arab responsibility for the present impasse? The Arab/Islamists accepted the land settlements the West set up as the victors after WW1, as long as it was all their land, but when it came to settling the Jews in the small piece of land that they have a deeper historical connection to than the Arabs or Islam will ever have, they could not stand it. The Arabs have a heavy responsibility for over 60 years war and terrorism that is aimed to destroy the Jews and take their land. The Israel bashing is so one sided and distorted that it should not have a place in public discourse.

      • Schlomotion

        I agree with everything but your last sentence.

  • g_jochnowitz

    As far as a democratic coalition in Palestine is concerned, consider the fact that a Palestinian woman was arrested for saying on Facebook that Abbas should resign.

  • Guest

    I agree.

  • Guest

    Those who marched on Jerusalem a few days ago demonstrated that they were on a romp of fantasy more than they were on anyything else. They must have been very loosely educated. Everyone knows that Jerusalem was the capital of ancient Israel a thousand years before Christ and sixteen hundred years before Mohammed. Jerusalem is mentioned in the Bible hundreds of times. Not one time is it mentioned in the Koran. For a place that Muslims claim is such a holy place of veneration for them this would seem to be an astonishing lapse. Jerusalem has been destroyed twice, beseiged some 23 times, attacked 52 times, captured and recaptured 44 times but it has NEVER, NOT ONCE, been the capital city of any other country in 3,000 years! This should be obvious even to those whose minds work in Schlomotion.

    The Arab/Palestinian claims upon Jerusalem are entirely spurious. They simply have no case nor do the so-called Palestinians have the slightest legitimacy. They are no more a homogeneous people indigenous to the region than the equator is a country. As evidence of this I cite an interview with Zahir Muhsein who served as an executive committee member of the PLO. This was first published on March 31st. 1977 in the Dutch newspaper, TROUW: "The Palestinian people do not exist. The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel for our Arab unity. In reality today there is no difference between Jordanians, Palestinians, Syrians and Lebanese. Only for political and tactical purposes do we speak today about the existence of a Palestinian people since Arab national interests demand that we posit the existence of a distinct 'Palestinian People' to oppose Zionism.

    For tactical reasons Jordan, which is a sovereign state with defined borders, cannot raise claims to Haifa and Jaffa while as a Palestinian I can undoubtedly demand Haifa, Jaffa, Beer-Sheva and Jerusalem. However, the moment we reclaim our right to all of Palestine we will not wait even a minute to unite Palestine and Jordan."

    This statement shows just how threadbare the claims of the so-called Palestinians really are and it should act as a warning to King Abdullah of Jordan who, judging by some of his remarks and those of his dimwitted wife, has been using his time on the throne as an opportunity to catch up on some sleep.

    • Guest

      Well-said, Paul! I agree wholeheartedly.

  • Guest

    As for the vile and counter-productive Olive Tree Initiative nothing one can say about its agenda can be too harsh. All bad ideas are good on the leafy campus.The OTI, the Rose Project which supports it and the Orange County Jewish Federation which helps fund it have all managed to align themselves with terrorist killers as well as an ideology that subjugates women, hangs homosexuals, persecutes non-muslim minorities and constantly repeats how it wishes to wipe Israel off the face of the map. What are we to make of this?

    On September 16th. 2009 a group of University of California students was taken to the disputed territories for a meeting with Aziz Dweik, a high Hamas official who was arrested by the IDF in January this year on suspicion of involvement with terrorist groups. No thought was given to what should be done to protect the students if anything went awry. After the meeting the students were asked to keep the meeting secret in case objections to it were raised! The whole episode was an outrage and a damnable disgrace. What is worse is that it was wrapped in the cloak of "outreach" a favorite tactic of appeasers who can't bring themselves to imagine that their enemies actually do want to wipe them off the face of the earth. This is the same sort of failure of imagination that led to the murder of 6 million Jews in concentration camps. Nevertheless, it exposed those who are unable to distinguish between COLLABORATION and EDUCATION. Confusing the two can be fatal. That time it wasn't but it is unwise to put one's faith in luck. It is far better to realise that terrorist organizations do not always behave in ways that comport with lofty academic discussions held in the Senior Faculty Common Rooms and at the High Tables of universities.

    And what of the Hillel rabbis who endorse the OTI? To listen to them one would think that the OTI is one long felicitous march towards enlightenment but when one hears hoof-beats one should look for horses not unicorns. One of the main goals of Hillel is to provide its students with an abiding appreciation of their Jewish identity and heritage as well as their vital connection to the ancient and historical homeland now known as the Jewish nation state of Israel. The rabbis will find that this best accomplished when not in a prostrate position.

    Mr. Barghouti is an anti-Semite as is anyone who endorses BDS against Israel. The charges against her are either trumped up or vastly exaggerated and usually heard in the kangaroo court of the Human Rights Commission while nobody even wants to mention how, until Israel regained control of all of Jerusalem in 1967, the Jordanians systematically destroyed synagogues and converted marble gravestones stolen from Jewish cemeteries into urinals.

    The atom bomb of accusations against Israel is that of genocide but it is the most easy to disprove. Since the mid 1960s, according to the U.N. statistics, the Arab/Palestinian population in the region has increased by 250%. Clearly, whoever is in charge of Israel's genocide program should be fired but the more serious point to be made is this and it is one upon which the leaders of the OTI, the Rose Project, the Orange County Jewish Federation and the U.C. Hillel rabbis should reflect: when they give assent to such obvious lies they cooperate with evil and in a very real way become evil themselves.

    • Guest

      Anyone who is familiar with the writing style of Paul Schnee will easily recognize it in the last two comments above. It's difficult to disagree with him since he always augments his facts with just the right amount of force sprinkled with witty nuances. If anyone would like to read his excellent work it can be seen on:

  • Almeda University

    its very nice post thanks for interesting knowledge