Impeach Pennsylvania’s Sharia Judge

Robert Spencer is the director of Jihad Watch and author of the New York Times bestsellers The Politically Incorrect Guide to Islam (and the Crusades) and The Truth About Muhammad. His latest book, Arab Winter Comes to America: The Truth About the War We're In, is now available.


Pages: 1 2

Indeed. With the OIC engaged in a years-long struggle to compel Western states to criminalize truthful speech about jihad and criticism of Islam under the guise of criminalizing “religious hatred,” Martin’s skewed and biased ruling is particularly ominous, especially insofar as it coincides with Sharia prohibitions on speaking ill of Muhammad, the Qur’an, and Islam.

This is why it is urgent that Judge Martin be impeached and removed from his post. Islamic law has now been involved in court cases in twenty-three states, while the Muslim Brotherhood-linked Islamic Circle of North America (ICNA) has embarked on a three-million-dollar nationwide campaign to whitewash Sharia and convince Americans that it is entirely benign, nothing to be concerned about at all. Yet there is no form of Sharia that Islamic jurists have ever elaborated or that has ever been implemented anywhere in the Islamic world that does not restrict the freedom of speech and require infidels to adopt a posture of chastened silence toward Islamic supremacism and Qur’an-inspired violence. And now an American judge in an American courtroom has validated the proposition that non-Muslims must not criticize or mock Muhammad or Islam in any way by ignoring evidence and letting go unpunished an attack upon an American who was exercising his right to free expression in a way that offended Muslim sensibilities.

Islamic supremacist groups in the U.S. such as ICNA and the Hamas-linked Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) are fiercely resisting the anti-Sharia measures now being considered in twenty states, and it is easy to see why: they would effectively stop or at least put a strong brake upon efforts to bring elements of Sharia to this country. They would put an end to the demand that American businesses and educational institutions must change the way they operate in order to accommodate Islamic law and custom. But with judges like Mark Martin on the bench, ICNA, CAIR and other Muslim Brotherhood entities in the U.S. don’t need to worry: Martin is already Sharia-compliant, already eager to set aside American law in order to do their bidding.

That’s why Mark Martin needs to be impeached, and soon. Freedom of speech and freedom of expression are our most fundamental bulwarks against tyranny. Americans who think that these freedoms cannot be encroached upon or eroded because we have the First Amendment are naïve. They’re already being encroached upon: Hillary Clinton recently held meetings with the OIC, the particulars of which have never been disclosed, to discuss strategies to implement the OIC’s campaign to restrict free speech in America. And it is only going to get worse, unless lovers of freedom take a stand now. Ernest Perce’s case is the case of every believer in freedom, whether or not one approves of his particular form of mockery.

Impeach Pennsylvania’s Sharia judge!

Freedom Center pamphlets now available on Kindle: Click here.  

Pages: 1 2

  • Ken

    Just another exmple of Sharia's slow creep into the American justice system. When the American public finally wakes up to the threat, it may be too late to reverse this dangerous slide into the abyss!!

    • King David

      Will the AMERICAN PUPLIC ever wake up.???? There is a certain faction of liberal(BHO voting Jews) that does not get the fact that SHARIAH has no place in our country or anywhere near our society. Why do they think this way? This is the type of thinking that leads to their BEHEADINGS–( It was the ovens in Nazi Germany)
      Shariah is Nazi–It is as simple as that. It has NOTHING TO DO WITH RELIGION. ISLAM IN our country is a political stance. There are Muslims in this country waiting for the ISLAMIST-NAZI'S TO quit. And these Muslims of a peaceful nature will do nothing about the ISLAMIST-NAZI-EXTREM ISTS. their mosques are buildings to plan war and keep weapons. Their koran is a book of instructions to wage JIHAD.

  • Alvaro

    This is just horrible. It is like the Mohammed cartoons all over again, where some people thought it was better to avoid Muslim rage and give sharia legitimacy than defending the constitution.

    That judge should leave the courtroom – in handcuffs.

    • Whatsinaname

      Beautifully put, Alvaro!

    • David Etzel

      Just shoot him and bury him with a pig.

  • http://www.resonoelusono.com/NaturalBornCitizen.htm Alexander Gofen

    The damage to our nation has already been done and huge. The nation is full of collaborationists like that judge. It will take years and immense efforts of the American people to reverse the islamization and to rid of islam in America.

    It will require efforts of millions people which must routinely show disgust to islam, display anti-islamic posters, burn and shred korans routinely at every Tea Party, at every conservative gathering.

    Only when such actions become routine and widespread, the collaborationist and dhimmies will get the message. And Mo-o-o-oslems will get the message too: Want be a Moslem – leave America for good.

    • http://yahoo.com jericho777

      Alexander
      All ya have to do is take a peek see below and know why. The Liberals this week, and are still wildly dancing over Andrews death, are void of any compassion and I am just finished playing nice, especially with the absolute filth they spewed and vomited towards this mans wife and 4 children. I said then, no more, that's it. and I can feel Rush's frustrations too. When you see these kinds of attacks daily it's enough to give in turn without thinking twice. And myself, I'm not even going to think about being courteous to these mud bugs!.

    • Asher

      People need to be schooled on Libal Lawfare…This is persecuting americans through the legal system through bogus claims to drain their resources through the courts and Judicial systems using Sharia.

    • alan g

      The Tea Party is not involved with the Muslim situation. It is about government overreach.

  • randy

    How come no bishops or cardinals were thrown in jail for the pediphile abuse in the catholic church.

    • http://yahoo.com jericho777

      Another misinformed Liberal magnet for stupidity! Every single priest that was found guilty was charged and is servicing other gay convicts as I answer your silly question! Go join Wolfy and make stupid children together! LOL Oh and I gave you both a thumbs down, you know what happens after that doncha? Your no gladiator, but gawd did ya make me giggle!

    • Rocky Mountain

      And this has what to do with the article above?

    • aspacia

      Many were jailed in spite of the church's attempted cover-up. The law got them.

    • standfast

      This is an oft-used method of obfuscating the principal of the matter. Lead people down another path, attempt to justify wrong-doing by citing other examples of wrongdoing, rationalize that this behavior is not so bad, because x and z did something worse, etc.

      All total textbook weapons of mohammedans who cannot bear to have their idolatrous "religion" criticized in any way. The insecurity and immaturity of mohammedans is staggering.

    • ÉamonnDublin

      Randy, And your point about the Judge's decision is…..? Éamonn, Dublin.

    • No dhimmi fool

      I'm a liberal. It's depraved idiots like you who give liberalism a bad name.

    • Oleg

      How come the teachers unions and school boards run interference for pedophiles working in the public school system? There have been many more cases of sexual assault and child abuse in the public schools but the perps quietly get shuffled to another school or another district when complaints are filed. In any event what does this have to do with a Judge take a foreign legal system like sharia into consideration in his rulings, they are supposed to follow U.S legal precident or the constitution, not Islamic religious laws.

  • Wolf

    ROFL. at you christians so into hating a muslim you are taking the side of an atheist in a legal fight. The irony is you are to dumb and enraged to realize the funny part. The Atheist knows what I know. You are just as nuts as the religious nut who attacked him. The idiot who wrote this article and those like Alexander Gofen above make it obvious

    • Rocky Mountain

      If you call someone an "idiot" be sure your comments are coherent.

    • jacob

      And needless to say, you don't believe that the idiot is none other than YOU ????
      I firmly believe this Pensylvanian judge and that New Jersey one who ruled according to Shaaria in the
      case of the wife raped by her husband, should be rather tarred, feathered and ran out of town..
      I wonder what made this Pennsylvanian judge convert to Islam as per his own words BUT IF HE IS, HE SHOULD KEEP HIS LEANINGS TO HIMSELF, AS SUCH BLATANT AND SHAMELESS PARTIALITY HAS
      NO ROOM IN ANY COURT OF LAW, AT LEAST IN THIS COUNTRY…..
      I wholeheartedly agree with this article writter:
      If people of his jurisdiction know what's good for them, THEY MUST IMPEACH HIM AND THE SOONER
      THE BETTER.
      Perhaps it would have a sobering effect on some other ultra-liberal or outright Muslim "judges"……
      .

      • WilliamJamesWard

        It will get worse before it gets better Jacob but in the end I believe Americans will not put up
        with the continual leftist BS and Islamist subversion……………………………..William

    • aspacia

      I am a Deist, and you are sterotyping, a huge fallacy.

      Secondly, there is a Muslim threat, and currently we are not threatened by any other group except Islamic terrorists.

      Thirdly, ad hom attacks are also a fallacy.

      Now, why not take your pseudo intellectual, liberal bs back to the sewer you slithered out from.

      • WilliamJamesWard

        Nice!!!…………William

    • pagegl

      Wolfie, you're dumber than a box of rocks. Folks, including Jews and Chrisians, on this site are siding with the atheist because they are supporting free speech. Simple as that, this is not a religious issue beyond protecting the Constitution from a religious ideology that would teat it to shreds. No one is hating the Muslim, they are, however, opposed to what Islam would do to the protection of our rights as defined in the Constitution.

    • No dhimmi fool

      I'm not a Christian, asshat. If "the Atheist" knows what you know, why are you attacking Christians for defending "the Atheist?" Robert Spencer is no "idiot," and I'm betting that you didn't even read the article, you barely literate fool.

    • Whatsinaname

      Wolf, please learn to write (and think) coherently. THEN you can criticize others for being idiots. Until, then, I would advise you to keep your incoherent comments to yourself because they make YOU look like the idiot!

    • RoguePatriot6

      "The irony is you are to dumb and enraged to realize the funny part. The Atheist knows what I know. You are just as nuts as the religious nut who attacked him. The idiot who wrote this article and those like Alexander Gofen above make it obvious "__

      You've got to be evidence of how a body survives without a brain.

      __Are you serious? We as Christians recognize the fact that our Constitution (the document that grants you the rights that you take for granted) are being violated it doesn't matter if that person is an Atheist, Jewish, Buhddist or not. If they do this to an Atheist and get away with it what's to prevent them from doing it to Christians or yourself, knucklehead.

    • vladdy

      Well, for one thing, we cibservatives don't side with a person because they're a Chrisiian or atheist; we side with people on the right side of the issue.

      And second, when you use 1990's style texting initials like ROFL, you give away your maturity level and iQ. This isn't your mom's basement; it's a seious site for political debate. If you can't get beyond ad hominem, don't try to play with the big boys (and girls).

    • MRobs

      You amazing moron. It has nothing to do with taking the side of an athieist – it is about taking the side of the laws of the United States a$$hole! The law of the US is very clear on this issue. The muslim assaulted the athiest for exercising his right to free speech – I know it may seem complicated to a clown such as yourself – but see if you can follow along. It is in fact against the law to assault a fellow citizen for exercising his free speech rights – see if you can wrap your tiny mind around that. The judge has incorrectly ruled in favor of the law breaker thus the judge has broken the law and can be impeached or recalled for gross miscarriage of justice – it is really very simple.

    • robert

      hey wolf,you belong on 4 legs,did your parents ever have any children that lived,your as useless as a onelegged men in an ass kicking contest.did you fail blocks in kindergarden,hug my left nut,if you know your right from your left,this is american jerkoff,love or get the hell out,with the rest of the musmutts,god bless all american veterans and all american citizens.semper fi

  • http://yahoo.com jericho777

    Hay numb nuts. Though he is an atheist, goes to show your dumb a-s that Christians are not judgmental, but you see, your a numb nut dumb a-s, and couldn't see the truth if it was slapping you awake! The whole point to our anger Twixie is the fact that this donkey rapist muslim rag headed turdnipple wife stoning honor killing Allah molesting pig grinding Muhammad butt lifter, is trying to force his shar'ia compliance religion upon us. And before you say Oh you wait a minute, some Christian you are, and your being judgmental, which I will say in turn, shut the hell up Perry Mason the wingless fairy monster. I am being discering, and what I have noticed and judged wisely you puke waggon, is that this muslim whore has blatantly broken the very laws he was to enforce, and in turn used Shar'ia to pass judgment down on the victim an American infidel while ignoring that his muslim a-s wipe brother broke the law and assaulted an American infidel.. And as for my name calling, you hut jumping jackass peckerwood. I am seeking deliverance and forgiveness from my occasional impatience with stupid idiots like your self… In short Peter Pansy Pud Cycle, go adopt a muslim wife beater and go ROFL over each other! And quit being such a Queen You Homo Erectus!

  • Anthony

    I propose congress immediately establish a fifth branch of the US Military to deal with the danger blasphemy against the prophet presents.

    The Infidel Task Force – 72 (ITF -72) would be charged with engaging and neutralizing threats to natural security resulting from misunderstandings enraging our Moslem brethren.

    The existing force structure is already sharia compliant, meaning the Infidel Task Force has a ready pool of trained, eager recruits to draw from.

    ITF-72 would be under the authority of Diversity Command led by Janet Napolitano. A second wing of ITF would be created by next year to comliement force projection within America and Europe called Multicultursl Task Force (MTF). MTF is charged with engaging homogenous pockets of non- diversity.

    Ministry of Truth

    Room 101

    END TRANSMISSION.

    • http://yahoo.com jericho777

      Are you talking about your Allah who married porky piggy and had a "ménage à trois", with little Muhammy, known as little hammer after Aisha left his perverted inbred donkey rapist soul? That Allah Akbar…

      • theleastthreat

        That was sarcasm.

    • http://yahoo.com jericho777

      Was Why I was asking. It's hard to tell where their stupidity ends any more or where it begins. No offence meant, unless of course you were? LMBO

    • Alvaro

      Don't give them any ideas. :)

    • aspacia

      Snarky sarcasm is welcome, and I hope others realize this.

    • PDK

      Janet Napalitano could not punch her way thru a wet paper bag. She is a coward.
      If I read you correctly, get some help, try to mature, you suffer from liberal illusion.

      • DogWithoutSlippers

        She is a three-bagger!

  • aspacia

    Okay, now what group is going after this totalitarian judge? I need to send them a few coins to impeach this seditious b@$t@rd.

    • WilliamJamesWard

      The Circuit he is in should be made known and letters of complaint should be sent…………William

      • WilliamJamesWard

        On second thought if this took place within a City boundary he would be a Municipal Court Judge
        and be subject to the ordinances of the City in question. If the Mayor and City Council receive
        enough letters of complaint and (bad publicity) the politicians will need to take action or fear
        re-election problems. No City wants the Nation looking at them with anger, way to bad for
        business and we are still dependent on the free flow of commerce. In the past I had two
        Municipal Court Judges appointed via my Council and they served at our pleasure but if it
        came to dismissal a letter of request to step down would be appropriate and final…………William

        • aspacia

          Tried, there is no email, only snail mail.

          • WilliamJamesWard

            I will try to google him as a Judge in Pa. later today and see what I get. Surely the local
            electorate when appraised of his conduct could start a recall which could cause the powers
            that be to act………………..William

          • WilliamJamesWard

            Judge Martin has created and uproar in Pennsylvania over his decision. His office was moved
            from Mechanicsburg Pa. to Carlisle Pa. over safety concerns, something there is no record
            of happening before. Cumberlain County Pa. has a District Court system and clearly Cities
            use this and thus it would be County Officials that would take action or promote it with the
            State. Possibly numerous venues of recall can take place. For now has been moved into
            the County Court House in Carlisle due to threats. This man served two tours of duty in Iraq
            as a Lt. Colonel in the Reserves and I guess he has been spoon fed PC garbage about
            how to treat the Islamist amongst us and it has carried over into his judgement. He has
            created a situation for himself that will mark him politically and the storm is in his court.
            William

    • vladdy

      It takes US, ALL of US. . I've written, everybody should, too:. And please help make this info and URL viral: :
      http://www.cjdpa.org/geninfo/earlymethods.html (email, call, or write)

      From their site:

      The Pennsylvania Constitution has always provided for the removal of public officials, including judicial officers, through the process of impeachment and trial of impeachment. That process vests in the House of Representatives the sole power to impeach, and requires the Senate to conduct a trial of the impeachment. Article VI, §5 of the Constitution requires the concurrence of at least two-thirds of the Senate members "present" to convict an impeached public official.

      • aspacia

        Thank-you much vladdy:-)

  • Amused

    Assault and Battery is against the law in EVERY STATE of the USA . Sentencing , fines or penalties etc . are at the disgression of the judge . The level of offence , class A /1st degree / etc .vary according to the severity of injury , age of the victim etc .
    This judge violated the very basic code of justice in every way .He should be impeached immediately . He's not fit to be a judge in the U.S.
    This is an OUTRAGE , and should NOT STAND .

    • dirtbag

      Yes, Atheists should voice loud against Sharia in the US.

      • Amused

        Why just atheists ? Are you just exercising some sarcasm or rhetorical point ? Or are you just being stupid ?

  • StephenD

    Perhaps this judge will hold court when all our officials, from the President, Secretary of State, of Defense, all the Generals; when all of them get what that ask for and "hold all those responsible (for burning the kitting materials in Afghanistan – the Qur'an) responsible.” Because they didn't do anything illegal by American Laws so they must be charged under Sharia. Since it is the desire of this Administration to indict them and he can't under our laws he must be imposing Islamic laws. This judge would fit the bill, yes?

  • 2thegates

    Muslims are sure that the US is full of the same girlie men they found in Europe that will acquiesce to their attempts to turn us into their “dhimmis”. They are mistaken. They are kicking the beehive and we are about to kick back.

    • Asher

      Rebellion is in the Wind…Big Time!

    • pagegl

      As long as we have enablers like Obama and his minions in office kicking back will be difficult, if not impossible. This administration seems to be doing all it can to help bring about a fundamentalist caliphate. So, I'm kind of wondering what he will do to prove he isn't bluffing. I bet radical Muslims everywhere laughed their derrireres off with that statement.

    • No dhimmi fool

      What most people don't realize is that Muslims tend to be very small. If they tried to sneak up on the average American male, they would like fail – unless they have guns.

      As the saying goes, Abraham Lincoln freed all men, but Sam Colt made 'em equal.

      When Muslims in the past have gone up against Europeans, they've gotten their asses kicked in hand-to-hand combat.

      So, please, STOP BEING AFRAID of these tiny and often inept megalomaniacs. Avail yourselves of your Second Amendment right, and practice self-defense.

    • aspacia

      Hornets nest is more like it.

  • PDK

    Islam is a disease of the human mind. It originates with a part of our personality that deals with our more mundane or animalistic personality, in Jungian terms, the atchytype of the shadow.
    Where the shadow can have positive imput under the proper ambience, it can also pass over into the realm of insanity when encourage to, and then further, protected for doing so.
    In particular, and of hugh importance here is the single most obvious trait of the shadow when pressed by the force of inferiority, his elicited hate and subsequent pursuit of superiority.
    This is the core essence, the heart and soul of Islam. Everything Islamic is seen through this single lens. Unfortunately and sadly, Islam today pursues its superiority globaly especially both in the West and here in America.
    As Islam pursues its superiority over the USA via a conquer, submit and enslave policy, the American Judge Martin has chosen sides and the side he chose was Islam. He should be removed immediately, an example should be made of him.
    America is the land of liberty allowing people to pursue their happiness. To keep it that way we must defend against all foes, foreign or domestic, Islamic or Judge Martin. Thank you.

  • richard handwerk

    hopefully americans will wake up and become politically outspoken, protest, etc. as other groups are
    each vying for power, one day we will be totally powerless.
    one day we may be terrorists in what was our own country.

  • DogWithoutSlippers

    The judge should be de-robed and unbenched! Furthermore, we need
    rules and laws that protect our way of American life and there must be
    preventatives against muslims attaining any law or judical position.
    BTW, what is this enemy judge's islamic name?

    • WilliamJamesWard

      Bat Rastid I think or worse……….Dishonorable Bat Rastid……………………..William

  • Anthony

    Someone please provide contact info for this nut job judge. A phone number is best.

    • No dhimmi fool

      Mark W Martin
      507 N. York St.
      Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
      Ph: 717.766.4575
      Fx: 717.766.2238

      Office Hours:
      Monday – Tuesday, Thursday – Friday: 8:30 am – 4:30 pm
      Wednesday: 8:30 am – 6:00 pm

      Complaints about the judge can be directed here (h/t Atlas Shrugs):

      Wanda W. Sweigart, Court Administrator
      wanda.sweigart@pacourts.us
      phone: 717-772-3771

      The Court of Judicial Discipline of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
      Pennsylvania Judicial Center
      601 Commonwealth Avenue, Suite 5500
      P.O. Box 62595, Harrisburg, PA 17106-2595
      Phone: (717) 772-3771 • Fax: (717) 772-3774

      Here's the homepage http://www.cjdpa.org/index.html

      The Court of Judicial Discipline of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
      Judicial Conduct Board
      601 Commonwealth Ave
      Suite 3500
      PO Box 62525
      Harrisburg, PA 17106-2525

      • Anthony

        Thank you.

    • vladdy

      Don't bother with the judge who's already lying his a$$ off and rapidly backpedling now that he sees people DO care about the First Amendment. . Contact the PA leegislature and/or
      http://www.cjdpa.org/geninfo/earlymethods.html

  • elitist

    Excellent article, but please provide concrete and specific information on how to campaign for the impeachment of this criminal judge.

    • leciat

      that was what i was thinking to elitist. could someone please provide us with the proper contacts to submit our outrage to

    • No dhimmi fool

      Mark W Martin
      507 N. York St.
      Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
      Ph: 717.766.4575
      Fx: 717.766.2238

      Office Hours:
      Monday – Tuesday, Thursday – Friday: 8:30 am – 4:30 pm
      Wednesday: 8:30 am – 6:00 pm

      Complaints about the judge can be directed here (h/t Atlas Shrugs):

      Wanda W. Sweigart, Court Administrator
      wanda.sweigart@pacourts.us
      phone: 717-772-3771

      The Court of Judicial Discipline of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
      Pennsylvania Judicial Center
      601 Commonwealth Avenue, Suite 5500
      P.O. Box 62595, Harrisburg, PA 17106-2595
      Phone: (717) 772-3771 • Fax: (717) 772-3774

      Here's the homepage http://www.cjdpa.org/index.html

      The Court of Judicial Discipline of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania
      Judicial Conduct Board
      601 Commonwealth Ave
      Suite 3500
      PO Box 62525
      Harrisburg, PA 17106-2525

  • person2person

    How can we help impeach Mark Martin when one does not live in PA?

  • BobSmith101

    Islam teaches a small percentage of its most devout believers that it is OK to commit violence in the name of Islam. Talaag Elbayomy is the perfect example. He believed he was doing his religious duty by assaulting Ernest Perce.

    Imaging a society where countless unseen religious fruitcakes like Talaag Elbayomy come from out of nowhere to do their “religious duty”. Everyone lives in fear when that is the case.

    Read my entire theory on this process at: http://islamsfatalflaw.blogspot.com/

    Here is the beginning.

    Would you wear a T-shirt with a Mohammad cartoon printed on it?

    You might in Montana. Don’t try it in Mecca.

    Why?

    Because, Islam trains a small number of its most devout believers it’s OK to kill. And Islamic killers have been trained to kill anyone who insults Allah and/or Mohammad.

    In Montana you’d have a good chance none of these Islamic killers would see you.

    In Mecca you wouldn’t last five minutes. One of Islam’s killers would come from out of nowhere and kill you. It is that simple.

    You don’t believe me? Ask any Muslim!

  • BS77

    the judge obviously got a degree in taquiya…that is, the obscuration of truth, lying, pretending, misleading and falsifying facts…..all for the benefit of the hideous ideology behind him. America MUST awaken before it is too late. Look at England and France….the riots, the assaults, the no go zones and the hysterical demonstrations…is this what you want ?

  • maria

    The three last years each month 90,000 Muslims came to USA under BHO patronage. BHO said in his speech in Cairo that " US is the biggest Muslim country". He and his accomplicies are working on it. Judge Martin either is Muslim or very aware of BHO and Eric Holder policy. If BHO reelected it will be the END of USA.
    We really need to know how in this case to campaign for that Muslim or just dhimmi judge.
    Article is good but advise us how to act. Other wise all is just words, words, words…

  • RiverFred

    The judge found it offensive, personally I find this fairytale so called religion offensive and it's followers which includes this judge.

  • Aranthus

    I have seen the video twice now. It is not at all clear, and in fact, it is so technically bad, that the judge was right to exclude it. If anything, the video proved that Perce and his friend were a couple of jerks. Granted, you have the right to be a jerk and insult Christianity and islam, and every other religion. But the video is mostly black screen with someone's voice over. It proves nothing. The police officer did not actually witness the incident, so his testimony is excludable hearsay. There really wasn't enough evidence to convict. As for the "recording" of the judge's lecture, it sounds chopped as if it has been editted. People should reserve judgment until they can see the official transcript of the hearing.

    • Jrupert

      Makes sense to me. A couple of Atheists, marching in a small town Halloween parade, decide to go into the crowd and beat up observers. One, dressed as Mohammad, makes the mistake of attacking a Muslim. Hey! I could be a judge!

    • aspacia

      Aranthus,

      The perpetrator admitted the crime!

  • Questions

    Thsi is as blatant an instance of judicial misconduct as can be imagined. Prosecutors at once should: 1) appeal the bench decision; and 2) bring forth civil charges against the judge. Let the word go forth that America doesn't adhere to Islamic law.

  • http://www.thoughtsandcommentary.com Dale Netherton

    The judge evidently has ignored what free speech is all about. It is about being able to speak without having force initiated against you by someone in disagreement. To elevate Muslim beliefs and sensitivity above the right of an American to express his opinion is unconscionable. Al people have beliefs and sensitivity and one should not be elevated above another no matter how many jump and shout in the street. Outrage goes two ways and I am outraged that an American judge is so ignorant of American heritage. Especially regarding a sect that attacked the United States in the cowardly manner they did.

  • John Sherwood

    I have been made to uderstand that islam is not a religion but it is a culture.If so then there are no religous bigots so no problem.The only problem that we have is that some ignorant judge like to think of his child molesting,murdering and ll of the other things I do not want to say because it might offend someone,idiot that they call mohammed.Like I said it is not a religion it is a joke on the world and a bunch of idiots are following the garbage truck.If they do not like the way this country is run then thay should go back where they came from and take their leader obummer with them.
    I am sure he would be welcomed home by all,maybe not his wife and kids because they do not dress muslim enough.Oh well that is their problem.

  • Kevin Stroup

    The Muslim who assaulted the American admitted he assaulted him. Case closed. What part of guilty as hell do you not understand?

    • pagegl

      Kevin, I tend to agree with you and I would have enjoyed the man being found guilty of assault. But, with the evidence allowed it wasn't so clear cut. To me the issue really is the idiot judge losing touch with reality and forgetting what the First Amendment is all about.

  • Gr82BGrn

    Wonder about the political persuasion of the Judge? Could he be under instructions from the AG? After all, the courts did not get to try the Black Panther thugs at the Voting Center. And, the AG did label the Ft Hood terrorist attack a "workplace grievance". It's not the US that has gone PC, it is the Administration and the AG (in particular.) And, I believe the term PC is a coverup for some serious wrong doing. Changing the labels is part of Saul Alinksy's tactics in Rules for Radicals. You know, the book SA dedicated to Lucifer. "By their fruits, ye shall know them"

  • Mad Max

    Well, let’s play to this game then. The Koran mentions Jesus Christ, but according to it he:
    1)Was not the son of God; 2) Did not die on the cross and 3) Did not resurrect. In fact according to the Koran Jesus Christ arranged to be replaced by somebody else, who died in his place, while he walked away. To use the words of Judge Mark Martin “And what you’ve done is you’ve completely trashed our essence, our being. We find it very, very, very offensive. I am a Christian. I find it very offensive…You are way outside your bounds of first amendment rights.” That means that according to any Judge Martin’s line of thinking, any Christian would have the right to attack any Muslim and try to choke him or her for the very circumstance of professing the Koran: Islam in itself represents blasphemy against Christ and any anti-blasphemy law should be immediately enforced against any Muslim.

    • Questions

      The last thing Christians should do is mimic Islam. Anti-blasphemy laws are an affront to any free society, whether in the name of Christ or Mohammed.

    • opar5

      You have it wrong, Max. People who are required to obey and imitate a madman in all things for all time have no other essence; stray from that pattern and they can be killed by any Muslim with impunity. If their wives or children stray from that pattern, "honor killings" usually follow. According to Islam, the Torah and Gospels have been corrupted, and the only true Jews or Christians are those in compliance with the Koran. To learn of Christian "rights" in an Islamic state, research "The Treaty of Umar." That's the law that should be turned on them!

  • WilliamJamesWard

    I wonder if Obama has put this malfeasant Mark Martin's name in for a Federal Judgeship or a job
    with master malignancy Eric Holder…………seems he would be a fit…………………..William

    • aspacia

      O probably will do this.

  • semus

    This judge should be impeached, stripped of his citizenship, and deported.

  • W. C. Taqiyya

    Understand your enemy. He is dedicated and completely serious in his intent. Name calling, hand-wringing, crying and wishful thinking about a bankrupt American system of justice is futile.

  • trickyblain

    Oh, you think those Photoshopped images you see on FPM headlines are real. You poor thing.

    Don't you ever wonder why the handwriting is blurry around the edges and in EXACTLY THE SAME IN ALL OF THEM?

    Probably not.

  • smoothlee

    Martin has to be pink slipped. And, I hope the door does hit him in his big ass when he's walks out. He could likely find employment with CAIR. He's just what they're looking for. They'd love him.

  • opar5

    Hey!! Don't you guys know Muslims are required to practice Sunna? That means to obey and imitate Mohammed in all things for all time – required over 70 times in the Koran: Allah's eternal, perfect words!
    Yes, Mohammed had everyone killed who disagreed with or made fun of him – including dancing girls and a poetess – that he had murdered in her sleep. My wife finally read "The Life of Mohammed" from http://www.politicalislam.com to get an understanding of Muslims. Read it with a Hi-Liter, because you'll want to go back and re-read some of the madman's insanities – that every Muslim is supposed to imitate – or risk death!

  • Eric G

    What would a judge gain by ignoring the evidence and favoring the attacker? One wonders how much payout he could receive from CAIR or some other such organization for doing so.

    • No Sharia Here

      In a circumstance such as this, IMO the anser eoulf be "Follow the money."

  • Robert Birdwell

    Judge Martin has combined, confederated, and conspirede with and aided, abetted those engaged in seditious conspiracy in violation of 18 U.S.C. Section 2384, to wit:

    If two or more persons in any State or Territory or in any place subject to the jurisdiction of the United States, conspire to overthrow, put down, or to destroy by force the government of the United States, or to levy war against them, or to oppose by force the authority thereof, or by force prevent, hinder, or delay the execution of any law of the United States, or by force to seize, take, or possess any property of the United States contrary to the authority thereof, they shall each be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than twenty years, or both.

    He should not only be impeached, he shouldalso be prosecuted for seditious conspiracy.

  • No Sharia Here

    I woould like to have an email address for this so-called judge so I can explain Sharia and the First Amendment to him. He obviously was absent from law school on the day they discussed the First Amerndment.

  • Scoffsmom

    I wrote the Attorney General of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania asking for an explanation.

  • gast

    ….and again – Phuck I’slam !!!

  • http://goo.gl/fjkbv Robert Hamilton

    I am here to say it is already too late to stop the Muslims from taking over the US. This illegal, phony, lying POTUS is helping their cause. You will see after this election. He will not lose no matter what it takes. Too many American legal citizens have other things that are more important and are too busy to take th time to do any research. They believe whatever the Media telld them.

  • Dave

    Canadian courts are now seeing Muslims killing their own members of their family in order to follow the Quran.
    One husband murdered his former wife and two daughters for being "too Westernized", and that he would do it over
    "one thousand times" because of not following it. Maybe they could all be angry with each other?

  • WilliamJamesWard

    Maybe a Turban award should be instituted for bozo conduct by Official persons in regards to Islamist
    intrusion, something like the Oscars or just one turban up or one turban down and so on depending
    what the turban head has done…………Martin gets at least 100 turbans down…………..William

  • Gary K.

    Can a Pennsylvania Judge be impeached?

    According to the Pennsylvania Constitution, a judge can only be impeached for "misbehavior in office" by the state House of Representatives. Articles of impeachment are then presented to the state Senate, whose members decide on either conviction or acquittal.

    Judge Mark Martin is the Magisterial District Judge for Cumberland County.

    Cumberland County PA Legislators can be found here:
    http://www.legis.state.pa.us/cfdocs/legis/home/fi

    If you wish to file a complaint, go here:
    http://judicialconductboardofpa.org/filing-a-comp

    Giddyup…

  • Richard Rhodes

    District Judge Mark Martin’s rational for the dismissal of this case betrays a profound lack of understanding regarding the 1st Amendment; this combined with his unprofessional and inflammatory commentary speaks volumes about his unsuitability to serve in a position of trust in any U.S. court–he should be removed from the bench forthwith.

  • Susan S

    Before becoming a judge Mark Martin served in Afghanistan and appears to have been indoctrinated by the radical Muslims there to serve as a Fifth-Columnist.