What Comes Next in the Mali War?

The French have won their battle, taking cities and towns out of the hands of Islamists. But taking sizable dense areas away from Islamists has never been very hard. Cities and towns in disordered areas are difficult to hold. It’s why Islamists were able to conquer them to begin with. But attempting to hold them will turn into a messy occupation as the Islamists regroup, terrorize the roads and begin recruiting native terrorists to carry out attacks inside Gao and Timbuktu.

The French government understands its military vulnerability. Its forces have smashed the Islamists, but the scenario is still the same as in Afghanistan. The Islamists pull back to the open spaces and mountains  to begin the long push back. Casualties mount, the war begins looking senseless and then the troops pull out and the Islamists take over.

But the French solution appears to be the opposite of the usual nation building program. France has made a quick deal with the Mali government and the rebel Tuareg MNLA, which is bound to keep the country divided, but does shut out the Islamists.  And France would like the African nations to send in their peacekeeping troops as soon as possible, though that is less realistic.

Hollande scored a political victory with the Mali intervention at a time when his domestic economic policy was flailing badly and his approval ratings were in the gutter. The approval improvement he gained from Mali is rather limited, but crucially it fights the perception of his ineptness and gives him ammo for his campaign against marriage and French traditionalists, not to mention France’s business community.

All of this however depends on a rapid withdrawal. Hollande knows it and so do the Islamists. Faced with the collapse of his domestic policy, Hollande explored his inner Sarkozy, talking tough and even threatening to deport Islamist Imams, a threat that he is as unlikely to carry out as Sarkozy.

If Hollande can’t get the infrastructure in place and the withdrawal looks like a collapse, his only achievement in office will be undone. And if he leaves with French hostages in enemy hands, the whole action will appear to have been for nothing.

Hollande doesn’t want to do any nation building, but he leaves a wounded Mali with the Mali military and the Tuaregs likely to resume fighting soon enough. And the fragmenting Islamists will find their way back into the Tuareg rebel ranks to repeat the same process all over again.

Still if the French maneuver works sufficiently well, then it may be worth using as a template. That type of rapid intervention, with a heavy reliance on special forces and rapid mobility, was what initially worked about the US takedown of the Taliban in Afghanistan. And it appeared to be the Rumsfeld model, until it was sabotaged in Iraq. Such rapid attacks and campaigns of destruction, followed by equally rapid withdrawals may be an effective means of destroying Islamist ambitions by crushing them at their moment of victory, when they have overeached just enough to be truly vulnerable.

  • JacksonPearson

    France can't let up, and take NO prisoners.
    They have to keep pounding the Islamists back into the dark ages.

  • Ziggy Zoggy

    I guess carpet bombing the jihadi hideouts would be out of the question. During the Malayan Emergency the communists tried to take over Malaya by splitting into small cells and terrorizing the population with guerrilla attacks. The British consolidated towns and cities and relocated those who could not be defended to areas where they could. They also rounded up potential communist recruits and relocated them separately. Anybody outside these areas was killed. The commies never recovered.

    This may not be a perfect model for war planning in Mali but it is a very good one. The local population hates the jihadis just as the Malayan population grew to truly hate the commies. Mali has no jungles to hide in and the jihadis are NOT Apache Indians. They CANNOT live off the land.

    The French aren't stupid enough to really care about hearts and minds and Hollande is a socialist which means he has no problem killing people to get what he wants. He reminds me of Obama and his drone strikes that way.

  • Pro-civilzation lady

    This is a very good analysis.. I like the idea of hitting the Islamists hard.. and quick.. at the point of victory.. and promptly out again..and again.. and again….How can we make Chuck or Obama see this strategy?? rather than the disaster of 'containment' without any might to back it up..

  • Ziggy Zoggy

    I guess carpet bombing the jihadi hideouts would be out of the question. During the Malayan Emergency the communists tried to take over Malaya by splitting into small cells and terrorizing the population with guerrilla attacks. The British consolidated towns and cities and relocated those who could not be defended to areas where they could. They also rounded up potential communist recruits and relocated them separately. Anybody outside these areas was killed. The commies never recovered.

    • Smote

      Carpet nuclear bombing of jihadi hideouts would be an even better idea. If Bush had done this in Afganistan, I bet the Taliban would be no more. A dead enemy can't regroup.

      • Ziggy Zoggy

        Yes. The jihadis in Mali are villagers and city boys just like the Taliban. They are complete pu$$ies and cannot live off the land like Apache Indians. Without villages to raid for supplies they starve, retreat or quit just like the Malayan commies did.

        Where can they hide in a desert $hithole like Mali?

  • crackerjack

    This article is nonsense. The "Rumsfeld model" in Iraq was to destroy the local secular forces and administration leaving the country wide open for Islamists, warlords and drug gangs. The French followed this idiocy in Libya and are now fighting the backlash in Mali.

    • Ziggy Zoggy

      Crackheadjack,

      your comment is nonsense. Your "Rumsfeld model" exists only in the anemic brain you share with all the other moonbats.

  • kyla

    I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of information useful for my research oily scalp.

  • http://cheaplifeinsurancetermquotes.com cheap life insurance

    This piece of writing is in fact a fastidious one it assists new

    the web visitors, who are wishing in favor of blogging.