Operation ‘Pillar of Defense’: One Year Later


MzU3M2Y2NzAzNyMvVnVGZVpFdUVMa1d2OWhvSmNDM0dZZ0p2S29NPS84NDB4NTMwL3NtYXJ0L2ZpbHRlcnM6cXVhbGl0eSg3NSk6c3RyaXBfaWNjKDEpL2h0dHAlM0ElMkYlMkZzMy5hbWF6b25hd3MuY29tJTJGcG1idWNrZXQlMkZzaXRlJTJGYXJ0aWNsZXMlMkYxOTIzOSUyRm9yaWdpbmFsLmpwZw==This November, southern Israel marks one year since the IDF’s Operation Pillar of Defense in the Gaza Strip. It has been the quietest year in quite awhile, with “only” 79 rockets and missiles fired at southern Israeli communities. This is the fourth cease-fire between Israel and Hamas in the past seven years, the first having been on November 26, 2006.

Southern Israel has sustained hundreds of rocket attacks during these cease-fires. The last cease-fire lasted from the end of Operation Cast Lead on January 18, 2009, to the first day of Operation Pillar of Defense on November 12, 2012. During that period, approximately 2,000 rockets and missiles were fired from Hamas-controlled Gaza, sending one million Israelis running to shelters with between 15-45 seconds’ warning.

The most important lesson that we as Israelis need to learn is that after the last Gaza operation, within seven years of the disengagement in the Gaza strip in August 2005, most Israeli citizens came under Iranian missile fire from Hamas-controlled Gaza, Tel Aviv and Jerusalem were put into range of missile fire, and the most heavily bombarded city was Ashdod, the fifth most-populated city in Israel.

According to Israeli intelligence sources, there remain in Gaza thousands of long-range missiles hidden deep within Gaza’s civilian buildings and infrastructure.  In “Operation Pillar of Defense,” Iranian Fajar missiles were fired near the Shifa hospital in Gaza towards Jerusalem. Israel renovated the Shifa hospital in the 1980s.

The “Iron Dome” battery defense system received a great deal of media attention during and after the Operation, implying that this was the military solution for the rocket fire from Gaza.  While there is no doubt this has brought about a change in the strategic warfare combating Hamas, it has definitely not solved the problem of rocket fire—far from it.

During the Operation there were five operational batteries intercepting missiles in mid-air.  As there are hundreds of mid-sized towns and cities in southern-central Israel within a 75-kilometer range of Gaza, it has been always a game of “Russian roulette” as to what areas or cities the “Iron Dome” could protect.

The Iron Dome does not protect the western Negev communities and the section of Sderot that is up to 4.5 kilometers from the Gaza border, because the 15 seconds it takes to fire an advanced Qassam rocket until the explosion in these communities just does not leave enough time to intercept the rocket.

Thus, a “creative solution” has been given for Sderot and the western Negev communities to turn into “the bomb shelter capital of the world.”  500 million shekels were invested only for Sderot to build 6,000 new bomb shelters, and up to 500 million US dollars to protect the western Negev communities in the 4.5 kilometer radius, including public buildings and schools.

As director for seven years of the Sderot Media Center, I can attest to the fact that Israel has not provided a solution to the rocket fire or threat, and that we should expect many more years of living through rocket and missile escalations, in addition to years of rehabilitation for an entire population that has entered its 14th year of living under rocket fire and threat.

The current “relative quiet” in the western Negev has resulted a near-absence of attention to the Hamas-controlled Gaza element in the current peace talks.

The ‘Two-State Solution’ remains high on the agenda of the Israeli government, as well as the focus of the Israeli media. However, hardly any mention is made of the “Hamstan” state established in Gaza, after the one-sided Israeli action giving “land for peace” on August 2005, leaving Gaza empty of a Jewish presence, civilian or military.

The lack of governmental and media attention to the current conflict between southern Israel and Hamas-controlled Gaza (even if it is largely at this point a matter of low-intensity warfare) in no way affects the very possible outcome of any withdrawal by agreement, or even worse, “separation plan” (of which Tzipi Livni is very proud), from territories in the mountain ranges of Judaea and Samaria looking over the center of Israel.

Ben Gurion airport, Israel’s only international airport, is less than 3 kilometers from the western Judaean mountains. The Sderot case has taught us that the most advanced technology in the world cannot stop a Qassam rocket followed by an explosion after 15 seconds.  One may ask: how many Israelis will live on the borders of a demilitarized Palestinian state?

Hamas today is in control of the entire Gaza strip and its population of 1.7 million Palestinian Arabs.  Hamas makes sure to remind Israel and the rest of the world that they won US and EU-supervised elections in all the Palestinian territories in January 2006.  Since then, there have been no elections. Again, one may ask: who does Abu-Mazen actually represent?  Who chose him?

In April 2013, during US President Obama’s visit to Israel, on his second-day visit to Ramallah, Hamas fired five rockets towards southern Israel, two exploding into Sderot.  One rocket exploded underneath a children’s bedroom of the Haziza family, and one rocket exploding directly into a children’s kindergarten.  This took place during Passover vacation, so no injuries were sustained, but the attack barely received media attention.

One million Israelis in southern Israel living within missile range of Hamas-controlled Gaza are asking themselves:  “If Hamas and the rocket fire and threat are not part of the current negotiations and peace talks, how is it possible to reach an agreement? Could we reach the absurd situation in which ‘peace’ is achieved and the rockets continue to be fired?”

The more we ignore the conclusions and policy Implications of “Operation Pillar of Defense” the more illusions we build.

Noam Bedein is a photojournalist, lecturer and founder/director of Sderot Media Center. He has conducted briefings and tours for government officials, diplomats, foreign press, and students from around the world. Recently he produced a short documentary for the US Embassy- ’Standing Resilient in Israel’

Freedom Center pamphlets now available on Kindle: Click here.

  • Rhaidon
    • Biff Henderson

      FOSCAM is marketing spam.

      • Rhaidon

        .,.yes.,.

  • Hass

    Can you imagine the pathetic uproar the MSM would make if the Israeli public fired back a rocket each time HAMAS did so?

    • PhillipGaley

      . . . . against naked aggression, I would say, they need t’return say, ten-to-one, . . .

    • PhillipGaley

      . . . . against naked aggression, I would say, they need t’return say, ten-to-one, . . .

  • Paul of Alexandria

    Start fielding the defense lasers.

    • PhillipGaley

      Yes, and air attack followed by D-10s, shoulder-to-shoulder, . . . scrape Gaza clean, . . . drive the inhabitants well into Egypt, . . . or Jordan, . . .

    • PhillipGaley

      Yes, and air attack followed by D-10s, shoulder-to-shoulder, . . . scrape Gaza clean, . . . drive the inhabitants well into Egypt, . . . or Jordan, . . .

    • Drakken

      I would prefer that the Israeli’s start using napalm, it works great in urban areas.

  • vladimirval

    The over $10 billion dollars Iran now has access to (due to Obama’s surrender to Iran negotiations) will bring more terror on western Israeli citizens. Perhaps the next generation of Iranian rockets will have nuclear war heads. How proud must Obama be?

    • Yasha7

      My guess is that he’s very, very proud.

    • Softly Bob

      It will probably bring more terror on all Western citizens.
      Not one penny should be given to these zombies, never mind $10 billion and to give such a large sum of money to a clear enemy is an act of treason, and Obama should be tried for treason.

    • Arf

      The Iranians recently celebrated one of their holidays: Annihiate America Day. Iran will finance the rocketing of small, poor Israeli towns like Sderot but when it gets nuclear bomb capability, it will go after bigger fish. Like the energy triangle it shares with the Saudis. And with submarines equipped with nuclear warheads, it will control at least 60% of the world’s oil. Then the American people will finally “get it.” But will Obama? Nah!

  • Drakken

    Israel, quit screwing around with those bloody savages, time to bring the total war concept to bear where these muslims are concerned, they fire a rocket, you level 10 blocks, arty works great in this roll. If they continue, A Sherman’s March through Gaza and a healthy taste of Carthage is what is needed and keep it. It will be a wonderful lesson to the West bank, which of course like a typical inbred muslim, they will still attack, so march in and make it pali muslim free as well. Everytime they attack you, take more land.

  • Arf

    The response you write about sounds nice. I like the idea but the Israelis would never go for it. Recently, the granddaughter of the dictator of Gaza was treated (for free) in an Israeli hospital for a serious illness. Said dictator would not even mention the name “Israel” but was okay with having his little darling treated by Israelis and paid for by the victims of his vile cruelty. Too bad he (and the Israeli doctors who treated her) never think about the Jewish children who are injured and forever traumatized by Hamas rockets. when the IDF strikes at Gaza, it is NEVER with the intent to end the terror but only to make a show of quieting it down a wee bit.