Open Letter to CUNY Chancellor Matthew Goldstein

February 20, 2013

Chancellor Matthew Goldstein
Office of the Chancellor
535 East 80th Street
New York, NY 10075
Phone: 212.794.5311
Fax: 212.794.5671


Open Letter to CUNY Chancellor Matthew Goldstein:

I write this letter calling for the resignation of Brooklyn College President Karen L. Gould and Paisley Currah, chair of the political science department for their unscrupulous actions in violation of students’ First Amendments rights, sanctioning blatant viewpoint discrimination, and promoting biased political propaganda under the auspices of the City University of New York.  As a former adjunct instructor in the CUNY system and a New Yorker concerned with how my tax dollars are spent in our publicly-funded City University system, I add my voice to the growing concern incurred by the college president and political science department chair over the irresponsible manner in which they handled the virulent anti-Semitic event on February 7 co-sponsored by Brooklyn College’s political science department, entitled “BDS (Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions) Movement Against Israel,” which serves to promote a global boycott of Israeli businesses, academics and institutions, and deny the legitimacy of the State of Israel.

The featured speakers at the BDS forum advocated boycotting, divesting from and sanctioning Israel, and have praised the terrorist groups Hezbollah and Hamas whose charter calls for the destruction of Israel and murder of Jews. One of the speakers, Omar Barghouti, founder and foremost advocate of BDS, has asserted that Israel is a racist apartheid state that has no right to exist, and he advocates for a Palestinian state to replace Israel. He is not only promoting a global campaign to boycott and financially harm the Jews, replete with activists carrying signs saying “Don’t buy Israeli apartheid goods,” but also sponsors an academic boycott campaign against Israeli academics and universities known as the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel. This offshoot of the BDS movement flies in the face of the noble mission of academia as “free and open exchanges of ideas.”

Barghouti’s unscholarly crackpot theories, lies and deceptions have been well documented and Brooklyn College’s BDS forum was a medium for the dissemination of these crackpot anti-Semitic theories. The BDS movement is not a campaign for Palestinian rights as its spokesmen ostensibly claim, or to protest disagreeable Israeli policies, but it is in effect political and economic warfare against Israel, seeking to dismantle the Jewish state.  For an academic department to sponsor such vicious propaganda is a breakdown of academic standards.

Propaganda and proselytism to students are forbidden according to the American Association of University Professors (AAUP) regulations set forth in 1916 that officially declared that students must be presented with both sides of an issue. The BDS forum was pure political propaganda and although Brooklyn College president and political science department chair were petitioned to allow pro-Israel speakers, they refused to permit diversity of intellectual opinion by authorizing a one-sided bigoted event where Jewish students were expelled and denied the opportunity to ask questions.

I am pleased to learn that you have asked CUNY’s Office of Legal Affairs to coordinate an investigation into allegations that Jewish students were deliberately barred, forcibly ejected from the event, and their rights of free speech were denied.  But more unsettling questions remain, which should be the major focus of investigation and punitive action. The question of why overt viewpoint discrimination and one-sided anti-Semitic indoctrination under the guise of anti-Israelism is tolerated in any academic institution which should be “free and open exchanges of ideas,” needs to be investigated and appropriate action taken to remove the culpable faculty and administrators  before unforeseen consequences materialize.

In order to clarify my concerns, let’s take a look back in history to 1933 when Hitler rose to power and became Chancellor of Germany and the Nazis won a large number of seats in the German parliament. What followed was the notorious nationwide Nazi boycott targeting Jewish businesses and professionals directed by Nazi stormtroopers posting signs everywhere saying “Do not buy from Jews!” Widespread anti-Semitism mounted with the Nuremberg Laws in 1935 depriving Jews of their basic rights as citizens and banning them from all professional jobs in education, politics, academia and industry which escalated in severity ultimately concluding in the “Final Solution.”

In November 1933, Martin Heidegger, the 20th century’s leading intellectual idol issued a decree applying the Nazi racial policies to the students and faculty of Freiburg University where he was rector. Jewish professors were fired and ultimately expelled from all German universities. When Hitler came to power, the majority of professors and students fell all over themselves to demonstrate their allegiance and obediently turned their universities into indoctrination centers for the Third Reich. The notorious book burnings took place, and freedom of expression, free inquiry, independent research and all objectivity was crushed under the jackboot of the “Fuhrer Principle” and absolute allegiance to the Nazi Party. Universities became the training grounds for the intellectual troops dedicated to serving Hitler for the extermination of European Jewry.

Ideas have powerful consequences in the real world and the seductive but destructive ideological precursors of Nazism - German romanticism, Volkish ideology, anti-Semitic mythology, Hegelianism, racial nationalism, social Darwinism – were percolating in the German university decades before the emergence of the National Socialism.  The renowned philosopher, Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel, was rector of Berlin University and his messianic ideology of nation-worship spread like wildfire. The Hegelian concept of Absolute Spirit culminated in the state as the “Divine Idea as it exists on Earth” and the Germans were the proud “chosen people” whom Spirit selected as its agent in human history, and the wretched wandering Jews must die out and be consigned to the scrap heap of human history. The human incarnation of Hegel’s Spirit walking on earth, to lead them out of the darkness to the promised Aryan land of true freedom, was the Fuhrer himself, Adolf Hitler. These 19th century academic ideological movements gave birth to the totalitarian political regimes of the 20th century and the mass murder of 100 million people.

My point is that when we look at the present day radical anti-Semitic ideological movements that are being given the imprimatur of respected universities and academic departments, this is remarkably similar to the malicious racialist ideologies that were incubating for decades in the eminent German universities that became the seedbed of the bloody atrocities of the past century. Thus the co-sponsorship of the BDS forum by Brooklyn College’s political science department gave legitimacy and an authoritative stamp of approval to the BDS movement, an extremist political propaganda tool for the destruction of the State of Israel. This is the critical turning-point where bad ideas start to become ugly realities. Now is the time to draw the line before anti-Semitic radicalism given legitimacy by Brooklyn College, escalates to its dreadful conclusion.

It is unacceptable for an academic department to sanction such extremist political indoctrination and to censor and prohibit opposing viewpoints. This corruption of AAUP standards must be investigated as well. President Karen Gould and Chairman Paisley Currah, need to be held accountable for permitting these academic violations under their watch, who like their rector forbears of Freiburg and Berlin Universities, have become the custodians of bourgeoning evil.


Phil Orenstein


Cc: President Karen L. Gould
2129 Boylan Hall
Brooklyn, NY 11210

Provost William A. Tramontano
3137 Boylan Hall
Brooklyn, NY 11210

Political Science Dept Chairperson Paisley Currah
3413 James Hall
Brooklyn, NY 11210

NYC Council Member Dan Halloran
166-08 24th Road
Whitestone, NY 11357
Phone 718-631-6703
Fax 718-631-6707

NYC Council Member Ydanis Rodriguez
Chair, Higher Education Committee
618 W. 177th St Ground Floor
New York, NY 10033
Phone 917-521-2616
Fax 917-521-1293

Freedom Center pamphlets now available on Kindle: Click here.


    Excellent letter.

    Naziism = Islamism

    Islamism = Naziism

    1941 The Grand Mufti meets Hitler

  • http://frontpage richard sherman

    Gould and Curran are dhimmis. They aspire to be the Heidegger’s of Brooklyn College. Someone should remind them of the wise words spoken by Martin Luther King Jr in March 1968: “If you are antiZionist then you are antisemetic”.

  • adinakutnicki

    Here's the thing – without the ISM and its attendant terror hydra, the BDS and assorted hate fests would be virtually nil. In fact, the ISM gives it the "activist" veneer, and the connections to real terror organs to terrorize the campuses

    Therefore, stopping the ISM in its tracks should be the first order of business. Having been immersed in this issue for over a decade, there is no doubt that the above thesis is correct.

    Adina Kutnicki Israel

  • bill Morgenstein

    Bravo Mr. Orenstein. Surely Israel isn't perfect. No nation is. Hold it to a high standard (higher than any other nation on earth) OK, but answer one question:

    If the Arab world and or the so called Palestinians are and were given land would an Jew be allowed to live there or even exist and would the world call what the "Palestinians" were doing Racist?

  • Rostislav

    There was a great time in the past when the United States had a proud name of the Land of Freedom. Seems that now, thanks to the general apathy and all-permissiveness, the name ought to be changed into the Land of Freedom for Evil Only… Just like the USSR or the Third Reich. Rostislav, Saint-Petersburg, Russia.

  • Bernard Baars, PhD

    Completely unforgivable. Larry Summers was fired as President of Harvard several years ago for dropping an innocent comments about gender and math ability. But NOBODY is being fired for a fundamental violation of academic values with the collusion of Brooklyn U?

    • stern

      That was just the excuse. Summers had also been supportive of Israel, a major crime in academia.

  • john in cheshire

    If the socialists were, for once in their miserable lives, to give an honest answer to a question : where would you prefer to live, a muslim dominated country or Israel, where would you choose? I suspect they'd choose their enemy; and still agitate for its destruction. That's how warped is the socialist mind. Just as these muslim immigrants come to our Western countries and then set about destroying them.

  • Bert

    A missing part of this story is the fact that this happens in the heart of Jewish New York with Jewish College officials. The ugly truth is that most Jews are cowards and Jewish intellectuals even more so.
    In 1991 there was a three day pogrom in Crown Heights Brooklyn against the Lubavitcher Jews.
    Black youths rampaged while the Jews hid out. Anti-Semites are very aware of Jewish cowardice and feel safe in attacking verbally and even physically.

  • Bernie R

    Do you have any scientific evidence to back that up, Bert? Where were the cops chasing the "black youths"? Where were you? Violence begets violence. What would you have done, tough guy? Gone out with your religious group and battle the gang?


      The Jews of Crown Heights should have had guns.

      During the LA Riots, the Korean shop owners had guns to protect their businesses.

      • Mary Sue

        well you know how it is with New York and Gun control…


      Bernie R.

      Violence beget violence?

      How do you think WW2 was won?

      Are conflicts won with a Peace Quilt?

      • Loyal Achates

        So you support the Intifada, then?


          I "support" your "intifada" AKA Islamofascist pogroms as I would "support" any other fascist onslaught.

          They must be crushed as the national Socialists were crushed.

          Any "palestinian" who doesn't like living in Israel can go back to their ancestral home in Syria.

          I hear Aleppo is quite interesting.

  • zdonate

    Good letter. Important point not made. While a university may promote and allow a diversity of opinions this was a function supported by the Department and therefore an opinion sponsored by the University. Much different than an open discussion or private group.

  • http://frontpage steve s

    Facts don’t matter to inane drones,Guru.

  • PermReader

    "Jewish anti-semites` appeasement"- If anybody support anti-Jewish actions he can be called racist,nazi or something.In the case of the Jew he can mercifully be called "self -hating"- poor chap.This affirmative action in Obama stile is quite dangerous for the Jews-themselves.

  • Franklin

    This post is really a fastidious one it helps new net people,
    who are wishing for blogging.