The ZOA’s Leadership Challenge

ShowImage.ashxOriginally published by the Jerusalem Post

The Zionist Organization of America is not the biggest American Jewish organization. It is not the most powerful American Jewish organization.

And it is not the most high-profile American Jewish organization. But it is the most important American Jewish organization.

Under the leadership of its president Morton Klein, the ZOA emerged over the past two decades as the only Jewish organization in the US that refuses to budge on its principles no matter how much pressure is applied.

Those principles of strong, unapologetic support for the Jewish state and the rights of the Jewish people to the land of Israel used to form the common denominator shared by most mainstream American Jewish organizations. But beginning in the 1980s, more and more US Jewish groups began abandoning this consensus position as liberal opinion shifted further and further away from Israel.

Today the American Jewish community is in a state of unprecedented crisis. And the need for a strong, vibrant, accessible and responsive ZOA is arguably greater than at any time in the past.

As last October’s Pew Survey of American Jews made clear, the American Jewish community is adrift. For most American Jews, being Jewish has come to mean being a liberal. This conviction is having a corrosive impact on major Jewish groups whose membership reflects the general sense of the community.

As Alexander Joffe explained in a recent article in The Times of Israel, the community’s equation of leftism with Judaism has made it impossible for Jewish organizations to withstand subversion by anti-Israel, and at times anti-Semitic forces.

As Joffe put it, these forces “take advantage of what has become a defining characteristic of the American Jewish community, an obsession with fairness and balance, an eagerness to listen to and internalize the narratives of others, to be ‘other directed,’ guided by external trends and standards.”

“Sometimes,” he explains, “this is justified as a Jewish value, akin to the ever-malleable concept of ‘tikkun olam,’ and sometimes as an American value.”

The result of this Jewish organizational determination to open Jewish doors to the communities’ foes is witnessed today among other things by the push on the part of some student Hillel groups to reject the ban on anti-Zionist and pro-BDS speakers, and the penchant of Jewish institutions like the 92nd Street Y, Ramaz Jewish Day School and New York’s Jewish Museum to invite virulently anti-Zionist and anti-Semitic speakers to address their Jewish members.

In Joffe’s words, today, “There is no institution, no space, no conversation that is immune from anti-Zionism.”

On the other hand, as he notes, anti-Jewish and anti-Israel groups feel no reciprocal need to invite speakers who support Jewish rights, power and the Jewish state.

The American Jewish community’s pathological desire to embrace its worst enemies is bad enough. But it is far from the only challenge that the Jewish organizational world faces. There is also the partisan political challenge.

Led by President Barack Obama, the American Left has exploited the Jews’ desire to remain in the leftist camp to dramatically weaken the power of American Jewish organizations to advance Jewish interests.

Take AIPAC, for instance. As Richard Baehr pointed out this week in Yisrael Hayom, Obama has used AIPAC’s commitment to bipartisanship to scuttle its goal of passing sanctions against Iran.

Baehr explained that over the past five years, Obama has shown his fellow Democrats that AIPAC’s campaign funding is far less important than funding from radical leftist groups like the public sector unions, teachers’ unions and environmental groups.

Obama’s actions have led the party away from Israel.

Since most of AIPAC’s members are committed Democrats, by decreasing their party’s support for Israel, Obama has forced AIPAC to choose between keeping its Democratic members and abandoning its agenda, or remaining faithful to its agenda and risk alienating its members by opening itself to criticism that it is becoming a mouthpiece of the Republican Party.

With 56 percent of American Jews claiming that pursuing justice and equality is essential to their Judaism and only 43% of American Jews saying that supporting Israel is essential to their Judaism, it is clear that over time, the challenge that AIPAC faces will only grow more acute, until the organization either becomes something else, or ceases to exist.

And this brings us back to the ZOA.

Like AIPAC, the ZOA is in crisis today. But the ZOA’s crisis isn’t about its direction. It is about its leadership.

Next Sunday the ZOA will hold its annual convention in Philadelphia and for the first time since Klein was first elected the group’s president, he is facing a challenge in his reelection bid. Steven Goldberg, a national vice president, is challenging Klein’s leadership.

As Goldberg points out, over the past several years, Klein has made financial decisions that seem improper on their face. They involve among other things Klein’s personal salary which appears unreasonably generous, and his less than transparent behavior following a temporary suspension of the ZOA’s non-profit status.

To be sure, these are not insignificant issues. And certainly, Klein owes the ZOA’s members and supporters an explanation for his actions.

But right now, the most important thing for the ZOA and for the American Jewish community as a whole is for Klein to be reelected. He needs to be reelected not because he is the only one who can do what the ZOA has been doing in recent years. He needs to be reelected because he is far better suited than Goldberg to maintain the ZOA’s current level of funding so that the organization can undertake a radical transformation over the next four years.

As more and more American Jewish organizations suffer from communal disengagement and political isolation, those Jews who remain committed will be seeking to affiliate with organizations with a clear message capable of inspiring them and their children.

The ZOA must be that organization.

But for that to happen, the ZOA needs to change its organizational focus and its organizational model.

Today the ZOA is very much a twentieth century, topdown organization. Over the next four years, it has to become a grass-roots, decentralized organization. The role of the national offices must change from leadership to guidance as the focus shifts to regional offices and local branches.

The ZOA needs to build a strong and always growing presence on the Internet. It needs to use social networking tools and viral videos to extend its reach to committed young American Jews who want to be part of a proud, inspiring Jewish community. And it needs to use its local branches to provide the educational, advocacy and social outlets for American Jews of all ages.

Mort Klein has led the ZOA unscathed through the 20 years of Israel’s attempt to escape reality through the phony peace process. Over the next four years his primary goal must be to recreate the ZOA organizationally so that the same principles and values can guide his successors as they follow his example of unapologetic, proud Zionism and Judaism as they lead the American Jewish community in the coming generation.

Freedom Center pamphlets now available on Kindle: Click here.

  • Tradecraft46

    I am afraid it is Jewish idealism which will be the end of Israel.

  • http://www.clarespark.com/ Clare Spark

    I wish this article had mentioned the division between supporters of the Irgun and mainstream Reform Jewish organizations in the 1940s. The trouble started there. See http://clarespark.com/2013/12/07/ben-hecht-v-ben-urwand-the-un-jewish-left-and-assimilated-jews/. “Ben Hecht v. Ben Urwand, the un-Jewish Left and assimilated Jews.” Caroline Glick knows better to have left out this structural division among American Jews during the Holocaust and the fight for Israel.

  • Habbgun

    It is individual commitment that is the hope of Israel and not anything like the ZOA. All organizations especially Jewish ones are doomed to fail. Jewish organizations put their finger to the wind and despair. Why wouldn’t they? Fighting antisemitism outwardly but not building up internal faith is a losing battle.

  • Lanna

    So beware of what kind of change you get…will it be to tell Israel not to accept 1967 borders, and to continue her settlements, stay a sovereign nation, with the right to exist… under new leadership? .At least Mort Klein warned people of the appointments of Kerry, Hagel, and Brennan who have been enablers of Israel’s enemies!

  • Yossi Jewy

    Morton Klein is a good man – but 20 years is too long. Time for new and fresh Blood. The salaries are nuts and its just time for change.

    • mackenzie wunderlich

      My Uncle Connor got Mercedes-Benz SLS AMG use
      this link B­u­z­z­3­4­.­ℂ­o­m

  • mackykam

    Zionism without Judaism at its core will ultimately fail. That is why leftwing Jewish organizations are drifting away. No Judaism at the core. Dancing the Hora at summer camp just doesn’t cut it. Neither does bagels and lox on Sunday do it. Or Jewish Sunday Schools. In the effort to Americanize only Jews left their religion and cultural identity behind. No other group did that.
    And if the Israeli government believes that their support in the USA still hinges on these Jews then they will come a cropper. Best they start making contacts amongst the Orthodox Jews of all stripes. They are the ones with the least amount of intermarriages and keeping faith in the ultimate redemption of the Jewish people.

  • Dov Gruner

    Come on Caroline Morton Klein does not know what the Internet is!!!!
    He makes millions has to go

  • spearofpinchas

    Mort is on the right side of the agenda, but he’s Mr. Ego, and a a perfect example of the adage, power corrupts, and absolute power…etc. Steve Goldberg from L.A. is an experienced, relatively young, hardnosed ,intelligent lawyer, a v.p. in the ZOA who’s a candidate for ZOA president and is challenging Mort to an open debate, which Mort chooses to ignore. Why doesn’t Caroline mention any of this? 4 more years with Morton, on top of the 20 he’s already been as autocratic prez of the ZOA? Ridiculous! And Caroline, I’m very disappointed in you and your poor judgement here.

  • Jabotinsky

    The only reported salaries for Mort I’ve seen are from Forward. That’s leftist rag can’t be trusted with anything. I’m not saying it’s wrong, it’s just the information that’s out there has been non-verifiable. I intend to get to the bottom of it on Sunday. I’m driving there Saturday night.

    ” his less than transparent behavior following a temporary suspension of the ZOA’s non-profit status.”

    Yes, well that’s the time Goldberg and Klein had the falling out. Goldberg was groomed to be the successor. He was running the whole West Coast ZOA. We see how that ended. They are both strong and sometimes stubborn individuals, conflict was hard to avoid.