Are Christians Behind the Major Arab Israeli Shift in Supporting Israel?

Daniel Greenfield, a Shillman Journalism Fellow at the Freedom Center, is a New York writer focusing on radical Islam. He is completing a book on the international challenges America faces in the 21st century.


IMG_1441-e1398169182859-635x357

This poll of Israeli Arabs is interesting and there are three ways to read it.

Between 2012 and 2013, “The percentage of Israeli Arabs who accepted Israel’s right to exist as a Jewish and democratic state rose to 52.8% from 47.4% the year before. There was a more pronounced rise in the percentage of Israeli Arabs who believe that Israel can exist as a Jewish majority state to 43.1% up  from 29.6% a year earlier. The number of Israeli-Arabs who accept their identity as such without identifying as Palestinians increased from 32.5% in 2012 to 42.5% in 2013. In 2013, 63.5% of Israeli Arabs consider Israel to be a good place to live up from 58.5% in 2012.”

Those are major shifts within a single year. But the years of the Arab Spring disaster have been heavy on change.

The poll can be read three ways

1. Statistical error

2. The Arab Spring has led to a major shift in the Israeli Arab perception of Israel

3. The Arab Spring has led to a major shift in the Christian Arab perception of Israel

It’s possible that the answer is 2 and 3. But 3 seems particularly plausible. Christian Arabs have suffered the worst in the Arab Spring. And they have the most to lose from Islamic rule. With the decline of Arab nationalism, they face a choice between Islamism and Zionism. And Zionism treats minorities a whole lot better than Islamism.

There are some signs of the shift already.

IDF figures for 2013 show a significant increase in the small number of Arab Christian Israeli citizens opting to serve in the military, a course that has long been taboo outside the Druze and Bedouin communities of Israel

“Since last June, within the space of half a year, 84 Christians have joined the military,” the army wrote on its official site earlier this week. That figure, while small, represents a threefold increase from past averages.

Father Gabriel Naddaf, addressing a gathering of Christian Arab soldiers earlier this week, called, not for the first time, for a radical shift. “As a Christian spiritual teacher living in the Middle East, I understand that human rights are not to be taken for granted,” the IDF website quoted him as saying. “I believe in shared life between Jews and Christians in this state and a shared fate between the Christian minority and the Jewish state. I believe that we have the capability to contribute to the state and I call on the children of the Christian congregations — enlist in the IDF, help protect the state.”

There are only around 150,000 Christians in Israel so that’s not as insignificant an amount as it seems. Going by existing age demographics, there would probably only be a few thousand Christian Arabs at the age where most enlist in the IDF.

The small number of Christians however also suggests that unless the poll was disproportionately weighed toward them they cannot account for the shift. Considering the events of the past few years, Bedouins seem unlikely to have become more patriotic.

The interesting X factor then might be the Druze who have seen what kind of chaos Syria has descended into.

  • Texas Patriot

    The demographics are still a little vague, but the overall message for the Middle East is clear. If you want to live in an atmosphere other than all-out jihad with everybody fighting everybody else all of the time, Israel is the only game in town.

    • Daniel Greenfield

      Yes, whether that message comes through enduringly is another question

      • Texas Patriot

        The ball is in Israel’s court. If Israel is steadfast in respecting individual freedom, human rights, and constitutional democracy, including a zero tolerance policy toward violent Islamic jihad, the message that Israel is an oasis of peace in a desert of perpetual war should be plain for all to see.

        • Daniel Greenfield

          That’s a Western point of view. The perspective tends not to be that rational in the Middle East. Look at Lebanon’s politics over the last two decades as an example.

          • Texas Patriot

            Its called the Reality Principle. And the reality is that Israel must set a much better example than Lebanon in order to survive as a constitutional democracy in the most hostile environment in the world. Someone has to serve as the bellwether in reviving Western Civilization. It might as well be Israel.

        • Chavi Beck

          Lots of things should be plain for all to see that nobody ever notices.

  • Qu’far Rising

    Come on, DG. They’re not Arabs any more than the Copts or the Maronites are.

    • Gee

      They call themselves Christian Arabs

      • Qu’far Rising

        The dhimmis do. The real men and women call themselves Israeli Christians.

      • Raymond_in_DC

        Some do and some don’t – which is only right, since some are and some are not. Many are indeed descendants of Christians Arabized subsequent to the Islamic conquest of the 7th century. Others however are of Greek, Armenian, Balkan or Assyrian background.

        While some of the latter aligned with the Arab national movement of the late 19th and early 20th century, that merely reflected the belief that it would tie their destinies to the nascent Arab nations. Ultimately that proved a mirage. Today more recognize that only under Israeli (Jewish) sovereignty are their civil rights protected.

    • Daniel Greenfield

      Not up to me. It’s up to them to decide who they want to be.

  • herb benty

    Great news!

  • JPFH

    This is an interesting development in light of a campaign in
    the USA to move
    evangelical Christians toward a pro “Palestinian” stance. As Christians here
    are coming under the influence of the anti-Zionist pro Palestinian viewpoint, the
    Christian Arabs of Israel are moving toward a support of Israel.
    Previously, the Christian Arabs of Israel have been greatly pressured and
    influenced by the Islamic narrative. Hopefully this new trend will continue to
    gain strength.