ACLU Defends Forcing Cop to Attend Mosque's Islamic Service

Muslims are not obligated to violate their religion, but Christians are.


Flip the table. Imagine a Muslim police officer objected to entering an Evangelical church or pro-Israel synagogue. The ACLU would be there foaming at the mouth.

An appeals court has ruled that the rights of an Oklahoma police captain that was punished in 2010 for refusing to attend an Islamic service were not violated.

As previously reported, three years ago, Captain Paul Fields was ordered to attend “Law Enforcement Appreciation Day,” which was hosted by the Islamic Society of Tulsa at a local mosque. The event, held on an Islamic holy day, was to include a tour of the mosque, an Islamic prayer service, lectures on the Islamic faith and meetings with local Muslim leaders.

“This event is not a police ‘call for service,’ which I would readily respond to as required by my oath of office,” Fields wrote in an email. “It is my opinion, and that of my legal counsel, that forcing me to enter a mosque when it is not directly related to a police call for service is a violation of my civil rights.”

The ACLU, a former Communist front group which some people occasionally confuse with a civil rights organization, has a message for Fields.

Imagine a police officer refusing to guard a Sikh temple, give a presentation on safety and crime prevention at a Catholic elementary school, conduct foot patrols in a neighborhood with a large Orthodox Jewish population, or come to the aid of an injured woman wearing a hijab.

Only one of these scenarios is remotely relevant. Fields has already said that he would have no problem responding to duty calls. The issue was an Islam promotion event. The ACLU has chosen to argue that Muslims are not obligated to violate their religion, but Christians are.

Tags: ACLU