No company has been as vocal about fighting for migrants and exploiting them.
“We’ve said it before and we’ll say it again: human beings can’t be illegal,” the ice cream maker declared. Its advocacy for illegal migrants even led to a clash with the British government which told it to “stick to ice cream”. In the United States, the leftist brand debuted a new flavor ‘Pecan Resist’, and bragged that it would “resist the Trump administration’s regressive and discriminatory policies” to build a future for “refugees and immigrants”.
The ugly truth behind the virtue signaling was that Ben & Jerry’s depended on migrant labor to make its overpriced ice cream. A year before Trump took office, the progressive company faced protests by migrant workers who spoke of having to live in barns without heat during the Vermont winter while milking cows at midnight and being injured by exploding glass milk bottles.
Ben & Jerry’s claimed that it supported open borders because of the company’s “social mission” and “values”. Those values were measured in the dollar and cents bottom line. The milk that went into the company’s ice cream depended on the cheap labor of those same migrants. Open borders wasn’t an abstraction, it was a steady source of labor to be churned into ice cream.
When the Biden administration rammed open the southern borders, flooding the country with millions of migrants, adult migrant workers were quickly supplemented by children.
A New York Times investigation found that Ben & Jerry’s was among the corporate brands benefiting from child labor. Of the various companies, Ben & Jerry’s was the most shameless about the use of child labor with Cheryl Pinto, its head of “values-led sourcing”, stating that “if migrant children needed to work full time, it was preferable for them to have jobs at a well-monitored workplace.” It’s an argument that sounds straight out of Oliver Twist.
Pinto, a former risk manager for its Unilever parent company, had been dubbed “Ben & Jerry’s sorceress” who focused on positive social impact. The sorcery turned out to be of the Hansel & Gretel variety with children being lured to the ovens of an ice cream gingerbread house.
Behind all the buzzwords about “equity” and “climate justice” are the children working so that Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield can get even richer while distracting us with virtue signaling.
Ben & Jerry’s has a lot of experience with “well-monitored workplaces” for child labor. The company, which has boasted of its support for Black Lives Matter, had been previously accused of benefiting from the slave labor of 8-year-olds on cocoa plantations in Africa, vanilla plantations in Madagascar, and palm oil on Indonesian plantations.
The open borders that Ben & Jerry’s had advocated for brought child labor to America.
In 2021, a Ben & Jerry’s franchise owner in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina was caught employing 12-year-olds, but the latest revelations about the company are a good deal worse.
The New York Times story describes a 14-year-old migrant boy who had his hand crushed in an industrial milking machine on a dairy farm. While the paper does not name the company, Ben & Jerry’s sources milk from farms in Middlebury VT where the accident took place.
Ben & Jerry’s and Pinto had previously made headlines for reaching an agreement with Milk With Dignity, a migrant workers group, at which one worker boasted that “I never had a day off before the program. But now I have two days off per month.” Ben & Jerry’s claimed that its partnership with Milk With Dignity means that the farms it uses no longer exploit anybody.
“Respect for human rights is one of our core values,” Pinto claimed.
The Milk With Dignity code goes so far as to bar “the threat or use of sexual or physical assault” against workers, which is pretty noble of Ben Cohen and Jerry Greenfield. Nothing says respect for human rights like agreeing not to sexually assault workers.
But the code only bars “systemic unlawful child labor”. That’s quite a few loopholes in 4 words. The full wording in the code defines “the use of systemic unlawful child labor, as defined by applicable law in the jurisdiction in which the farm is located.” That’s as good as an admission. Child labor can be systemic or it can be unlawful, but it can’t be both systemic and unlawful.
Behind the meaningless organic labels and the images of bucolic cows and photogenic hipster farmers marketed by progressive upselling brands like Ben & Jerry’s is a dairy industry that, despite its location across the country, looks a lot like California’s illegal alien farms.
A local paper described “the coyotes who smuggle migrants across the border, the people who run safe houses, the van drivers who make regular interstate and cross-country runs, and the farmers are part of a complex, underground system powered by cell phones and money.”
“Sex traffickers are a small part of that network. Most of the dairy workers are young men stuck on rural farms with no transportation. Enter the pimps who, exploiting the loneliness and isolation of the workers, drive women to remote farms. A prostitution ring in Vermont came to light in 2011, when police arrested two men who brought women to have sex with workers for $60 a trick.”
“They just bring girls, Mexicans and Colombians, mostly Latinas,” Carlos, who came to the country as an “unaccompanied minor”, told a journalist.
That’s the grim reality behind all the hipster brands and leftist politics, the cutesy celebrity names, the photos of woke icons like Stephen Colbert and Ava DuVernay, are Mexican teens living in unheated barns and working to milk cows twice a day in between visits to trafficked girls. It’s little wonder that Ben & Jerry’s keeps searching for new radical causes to embrace.
In 2021, Ben & Jerry’s announced that it was joining a boycott of Israel because selling ice cream in the Jewish State was “inconsistent with our values”. The move came at the behest of Anuradha Mittal, the Ben and Jerry’s social justice board chairwoman, who had defended Hamas and Hezbollah, and whose offices were decorated with a “Support the Intifada” poster.
Selling ice cream in Israel was inconsistent with Ben & Jerry’s values, child labor wasn’t.
Ben & Jerry’s support for BDS and for other radical leftist causes like BLM came as it was trying to divert attention from the products and processes at the heart of its business. Its social justice logorrhea has led the company in just the last month to endorse critical race theory as a “long-overdue correction to the whitewashed history taught in most American schools”, to claim that brain injuries are worse for black people and to endorse slavery reparations. Much like hating Israel, none of this has anything to do with ice cream. And that’s the whole point.
Like a criminal in police custody, Ben & Jerry’s would like to talk about anything and everything in the world except its own crimes. Smearing Israel, America, Jews, white people and anyone else is a convenient distraction from the fact that the social justice ice cream empire is built on child labor and on the open borders it champions and whose exploitation it benefits from.
Ben & Jerry’s talks nonstop about its values. What are its actual values beyond its hashtags about BLM, open borders, Israel, sexism, transphobia and climate justice? As Groucho Marx quipped, “Those are my principles, and if you don’t like them… well, I have others.”
The only values of the ice cream, that is uniquely flat and tasteless in all its diversity of overpriced social justice flavors, are what it does, not what it claims to believe. One of those revealing moments came some years ago when migrant workers protested in a march to the Ben & Jerry’s factory. A few of the illegal aliens were arrested.
“We are concerned that hard-working, productive members of our community, who contribute to the success of dairy farms in Vermont, would face criminalization,” Ben & Jerry’s said, in a statement that had a very different tone than its usual bellicose social justice tweets. “We need policy change that serves Vermont’s dairy workers, farmers, and industry as a whole.”
That was the sound of Ben & Jerry’s talking about the intersectionality of its support for open borders and its business model that depended on illegal aliens. Another came when its values sourcing boss responded to the New York Times story by suggesting that, “If migrant children needed to work full time, it was preferable for them to have jobs at a well-monitored workplace.”
Those are Ben & Jerry’s real values. They’re not as marketable, but unlike the others, they’re true.
Algorithmic Analyst says
Thanks Daniel, good expose.
Jeff Bargholz says
Yeah, I didn’t know most of that stuff.
Sorry I downvoted by accident!
roberta says
Hippies and wannabe hippies suck. The Counter Culture Movement is were misfits can feel at home. It gives them the
right to be of no good use whatsoever, and a platform to criticize those who make the world turn.
Not that it has anything to do with Ben and Jerry, they are phonies on every level.
Daniel Greenfield says
All the capitalist hippies are.
Jeff Bargholz says
I liked the much better in “City Slickers.”
Spurwing Plover says
Ben & Jerry supports the Eco-Freaks they took part in the Save the Rain Forests 1990’S and now they support Child Labor More reasons to Boycott them
CowboyUp says
Typical leftist hypocrisy. They can’t be expected to do the right thing unless it’s mandated by law, and even then, they try every way possible to get out of following it. No wonder they need so many rules, laws, and regulations, and they can’t self-govern, but must be ruled.
Never tried ben and jerry’s, but I heard they were lefties early. Mathis Dairy, Southern Dairies, and Mayfield ice cream has always been fine with me. Some idiot was on here earlier blaming Judaism (what won’t it get blamed for?) for ben and jerry’s, but it looks like his asinine post and my rude smackdown reply got scrubbed.
Jeff Bargholz says
Tillamook ice cream is great and so is Thrifty, even with the cheesy and bargain basement containers it uses. So is Safeway’s ice cream. Breyer’s and Dryer’s are OK.
Even if Ben and Jerry and the company which owns that brand of ice cream were ultra cool conservatives, I wouldn’t buy it because it tastes crappy and is overpriced.
Steven Brizel says
Great report! There are far better and far less woke brands of ice cream
Daniel Greenfield says
Virtually any ice cream you get is better and a better value.
The more a product has to tell you about its values, the less value it has.
Elmer says
Most Usraelis hate Ben n Jerrys due to their hatred of Israel. Because of the parent company Unilever (which also distributes other well known products), they stronger companies into making them akso buy B&Js – last they wont get their Telma products like corn flakes. Due to the prevalence of monopoly amd price fixing, Israeli suffer from a lack of competing products. Fortunately there is Nestle – another mega conglomerate – that also has ice cream (less tasty, but a LOT more appealing!
Daniel Greenfield says
My impression is BJ doesn’t have much appeal in Israel except to wealthy hipsters.
Joe Biden says
I like it and I’m a Jewish black hispanic indigenous trans sniffer.
Taylor says
Judicial reform is THE critical step to reigning-in Israels gross overregulation by the bureaucrats, histadrut, ILA and its’ monopolies-oligopolies. Once judicial reform goes through, the bread and butter issues will be tackled. Just an FYI.
Houmynmn says
It would be nice if a much less sugary, creamier ice cream was easily available. here in the States. But, Alas, no market for one. So if you want it you make it. But there is no doubt that B & J ‘s is not healthful.
Tex the Mockingbird says
Forget Ben & Jerry look up Star Spangled Ice Cream they have better flavors
112 says
You can have your exploited illegals, but eventually you get exploited kids like in South America, everywhere.
They probably boycotted Israel because they couldn’t find any kids to work.
Spurwing Plover says
Those idiots from PETA wanted them to use Human Milk in their Ice Creams
Andrew Blackadder says
The hypocrisy knows no bounds with these self righteous mega rich communist capitalists virtue signalling to morons that cant think for themselves.
Like the wonderful people of Martha’s Vineyard with their big sign at the gate of their town, immigrants are welcome here… For 24 hours…. Then we wave those lovely folks bye bye…
Of course those two fat morons want open borders as they need the cheap Labor to make their overpriced Ice Cream.
I heard one of them scream about Trump and the cages at the Southern Border when those ”cages” were built under Obummer, oops I meant Obama… But CNN does not want anybody to know that FACT… Just follow zee orders.
This is THE worse Administration EVER and there is two more years to go.
Can America survive is THE question of the day.
Spurwing Plover says
Sink or swim frankly those two nutbars should stay inland
Steven Burstein says
But Unilever owns Ben and Jerry’s. How much control do Ben and Jerry have now? And those migrants on farms don’t work directly for Ben and Jerry, Unilever buys from them, I think.
Hannah54 says
Excellent call-out.
I would even call it a prophet’s work, given that B & J are (at least in name) members of the Tribe and are therefore accountable to terms of the Divine Covenant made with Israel.
I can’t help wondering where the Torah-observant community is on the issue of public rebukes to fellow Jews, and why Daniel Greenfield is such a rare phenomenon.
I hear endless rabbinic teachings about avoiding the evils of “lashon harah” (any public exposure of wrongdoing among Jews – even when it’s true), and not so much about our obligation to “undo the bonds of wickedness and break every yoke” (Isaiah 58:6).
Daniel, do you get support for what you do from the rabbinic community?