Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
When your country has invaded and over a thousand of your people have been murdered, do you
A. Smash Those Responsible
B. Focus on Your Reputation
America initially went with A after 9/11. And then decided to spend the next 20 years on B mode.
Israel is now understandably in A mode after spending even longer in B mode after the Oslo Accords. This is understandable to anyone who is a normal human being and therefore unemployable at the State Dept.
Assistant Secretary of State Bill Russo, overseeing global public affairs in the State Department, told Israeli foreign ministry officials in a call on March 13 that both the U.S. and Israel face a “major credibility problem” as a result of the “unpopular” Israeli military offensive in Gaza.
“The Israelis seemed oblivious to the fact that they are facing major, possibly generational damage to their reputation not just in the region but elsewhere in the world,” the memo says. “We are concerned that the Israelis are missing the forest for the trees and are making a major strategic error in writing off their reputation damage.”
The Israelis are too busy trying to win a war to worry about “reputation damage” since everything Israel does, beginning with merely existing, inflicts “reputation damage” since much of the Left and Islam spend much of their time launching every possible smear at Israel.
Israel was being accused of genocide even before Oct 7 for not letting Hamas invade Israel to kill Jews. Fighting back against Hamas is definitely genocide. Anything short of Jewish genocide is… genocide.
Israel is not going to win a “reputation” game, it can however rebuild its reputation of being too dangerous to attack. That’s worth a whole lot more in the Middle East than trying to win friends and influence enemies with territorial concessions and appeasement.
There are lessons here for America that the State Department is eager that we never ever learn.
SPURWING PLOVER says
Our State Dept run by the CFR/DNC/Globalists
Greg says
Israel to U.S. State Department: “Go to Haiti.”
blennos says
Insight such as expressed in this short piece demonstrate why, in this household, we refer to the author as “The Great Greenfield.”
Many in the world are shocked that, as per usual, Israel is not deferring to the wishes for “restraint” of their “benefactors” in the West. As I told my wife on the day this happened: “This time is different .” Israel will go all the way. And they must.
The difference? Three reasons. This time the muslims went too far in their savagery. Israel has gotten too strong to meekly accept their own destruction. And the West has become pathetically weak.
Daniel Greenfield says
and the West’s alliance with the enemy has only deepened since Obama
Gordon says
Every day is opposite day at the State Department.
Domenic Pepe says
How come after 1400 years of ongoing bloody aggression depravity psychopathology murder and all
encompassing hatred and violence for all non- Moo — Slums,
Islam never suffers from a so-called “generational damage to their reputation” ?
The Biden State Department has got its head up its stinkin’ filthy arsehole.
The current US government is literally out of its mind.
No matter what great evils they perpetrate …..
Islam never suffers from a so-called “generational damage to their reputation” .
Noah Andeark says
The problem with Israel (and Jews), according to Democrats, is that they don’t want to die. The only way Cabbage Brain Biden can earn the terrorist votes back in some swing states is to provide lots and lots of dead Jews. That’s what the muslims respect. Dead Jews.
Jojo compares himself to FDR. I agree. When I think of FDR I think of Americans being placed in concentration camps and for sending Jews to Germany so they could be killed.
roberta says
This stupid comment out of the State Dept. was no doubt thought up by one or more “”Career”” lifers.
Every word or action of a government ”lifer” is about nothing but their career.
It doesnt matter if they are military, CIA, FBI, or in the Agriculture dept, a lifer is useless.
How about a big glass of stfu, worry about the safety of the USA, and let Israel take out their trash.
Daniel Greenfield says
they’re the products of institutions controlled by America’s enemies and funded by regimes like Qatar
Kynarion Hellenis says
Israel’s reputation should rightly put fear into the hearts of her enemies. I hope she gets a new feast day.
Algorithmic Analyst says
The October 7 attack was just the initial attack to prepare the way for the main attack Sinwar had scheduled for some hours later. Fortunately by then it was too late since Israeli forces had been mobilized. If the main attack had been launched very soon after the initial attack it could have been big trouble.
NAVY ET1 says
Obviously there are no mirrors inside the State Department buildings, otherwise they’d be able to see that complaining about Israel “writing off their reputation damage” is the epitome of projection and the height of hypocrisy.
Greg says
If “there are no mirrors inside the State Department buildings” it’s because, like Dracula, “woke” diplomats cast no reflection.
RAM says
When world opinion tells you to submit and die like gentlemen, tell the world to stuff it.
Bryan says
Israel is doing what needs to be done while making the effort to minimize collateral damage. It is not their fault that Hamas chooses to hide surrounded by others and it is not their fault Gazans accept Hamas hiding amongst them.
Why should that damage their reputation? It is better than letting Hamas rebuild and strike again.
I look at the US and our growing debt problem. Politician after politician on both sides of the aisle put it off for others to deal with and the problem grows worse.
In the lead up to WWII, the future allies told Germany, “OK, you can have this country but go no further” followed by “OK, you can have that country, but go no further” followed by “OK, you can have the other, but go no further.”
At least Israel is facing up to the problem. If anything, Israel’s reputation as a serious country should grow.
Quote: Assistant Secretary of State Bill Russo, overseeing global public affairs in the State Department, told Israeli foreign ministry officials in a call on March 13 that both the U.S. and Israel face a “major credibility problem”…
Yes, the US faces a major credibility problem. The US is not currently willing to stand for what is right. How much credibility did Neville Chamberlain have?
John Sweet says
The State Department employees act in their own self-interest. How many diplomatic jobs are there in Arab and Muslim countries? How many in Israel?
Mike says
For thousands of years people all over Europe and the Middle East slaughtered and persecuted Jews as they pleased, secure in the knowledge that the Jews, stateless and powerless, could not defend themselves.
Jews lived at the mercy of the people of whatever place they found themselves.
Now, once again, Palestinians are determined to slaughter Jews and do so with glee at every opportunity.
But, since 1948, the Jews have a state and a military and the means to defend themselves as best they can from those who are determined to destroy them.
And the Politically Correct World cannot stand it.
Now the Politically Correct among us say that if the Jews have the nerve to actually defend themselves from those determined to slaughter them they must do so perfectly. There can be no Collateral Damage. No Palestinian civilians must be killed or harmed. No Gaza infrastructure must be harmed. No Palestinian children must suffer.
In short, the Palestinians must suffer no adverse consequences from their decision to attack Israel and slaughter Jews on October 7,.
Of course, no people fighting a defensive war against those who seek to slaughter them have ever been held to this standard.
Only the Jews have this impossible standard imposed on them when they are fighting those who have no standards of decency or civilized behavior.
Only Jews are condemned at being Oppressors when they actually defend themselves and refuse to go quietly to their deaths.
Domenic Pepe says
I am really glad that Israel possesses about 200 to 300 nuclear weapons.
The 1400 year scourge on humanity of depraved psychopathic murderous Islam may be close to an end.
Hava (from Israel) says
I hope this is true, that we have 2-300 nuclear weapons! It would serve our enemies and frenemies right.
Darrel says
Israel should do what the Quran says (with some minor changes):
Quran (3:151) – “Soon shall We cast terror into the hearts of the Terrorists, for that they joined companions with Yawneh, for which He had sent no authority”
The Torah is just too good.
BLSinSC says
Many years ago a lot of those folks occupying space in Our State Department would be under lock and key and supervised by men in White Jackets and have their medication given to them on a REGULAR basis! OR they would be in PRISON awaiting their EXECUTIONS for TREASON!
mj says
I believe the UN is not long for this world. Anything built on a foundation of lies, hate and terror will fail.
May the IDF find, rescue and bring home all the hostages. Like ancient Pharoah, the UN and countries who ‘negotiate’ with terrorists won’t ‘let our people go’.
May the IDF speedily grind Hamas into dust.
May God instill fear in the evil hearts of all of Israel’s enemies.
My God spread the shelter of peace over us.
Dr. Dre says
The UN AND the City of New York both seem to be circling the drain into the East River right about now. How much worse can it get?, you ask. Hold my beer.
CowboyUp says
I prefer a reputation that there are some things you just don’t do. It stops a lot of trouble before it starts.
Mark Stately II says
The State Dept is in:
1) .A state of mental and ethical confusion
2) A state of denial of reality
3) A state of moral bankruptcy and appeasement to terror
4) A state of fear of losing the pro-terror vote
5) A state of reckless endangerment to Israel
6) All of the above
Martina Vaslovik says
Amazing that when Hamas and the Gazans start a war they are now losing it somehow becomes a genocide on the part of Israel who they attacked in the first place.
TruthLaser says
After Moses led his people to the promised land that many had much earlier left to go to Egypt during famine, Joshua led the people into their own state. The Pharaoh was not asked for permission. Biden could be right about one thing. He just could be a greater authority on reputational damage than any pharaoh.
Algorithmic Analyst says
Speaking of reputations, Sinwar has ruined his reputation as a strategist after botching the October 7 operation. History of strategy shows it is very difficult to get the timing right for 2 seperate parts of an operation, like the initial attack on October 7, which succeeded beyond Sinwar’s expectation, and the main attack which he planned to follow several hours later.. History is littered with the failures of combined operations where one part came too late to assist the other part. If he had read history he should have known that.