Getting your Trinity Audio player ready...
|
The media is freaking out after former President Trump told black journalists about Kamala, “I’ve known her a long time indirectly — not directly very much — and she was always of Indian heritage and she was only promoting Indian heritage. I didn’t know she was black — until a number of years ago when she happened to turn black.” And now she wants to be known as black, so I don’t know is she Indian or is she black … but you know what, I respect either one, but she obviously doesn’t.”
Kamala and Obama were both ‘third culture’ children raised by non-black mothers and abandoned by their black fathers who grew up in third countries (Indonesia for Obama and Canada for Kamala) who had limited connections to any sense of blackness until they moved to America and began working on their careers. Kamala at least attended Howard and had tried to socialize with other black people, Obama hardly did. Both Kamala and Obama had mothers who were non-black radicals with a hankering for black nationalism. Obama related to blackness mostly through the lens of politics. Kamala likely does too.
A core difference between the invention of Kamala and Obama’s blackness is that Obama launched his national career with a bestselling ‘memoir’ laying out a fictionalized version of his embrace of blackness.
Kamala has really not done so and probably couldn’t. She’s many things but an intellectual, even a fake one, isn’t one of them.
There’s a video to back it up. pic.twitter.com/eugKnYU2C5
— Savannah (@BasedSavannah) July 31, 2024
But another difference is that while Obama never formally identified as white (Muslim or Indonesian may be another matter), Kamala did identify as Indian. And still does. The pitch for her tends to go back and forth.
Trump isn’t wrong here, the media is once again uncomfortable with the question of a non-African American ‘black’ candidate whose roots are not American and do not come out of the slavery experience.
That’s also a sensitive issue for many African Americans. Most black Americans did eventually come to accept Obama as one of their own. But he was a much better mimic while Kamala has a history of awkward and tone-deaf efforts to appear black.
Entire academic fields now revolve around blackness, as authentic, and of whiteness as a construct. Talking about blackness as a construct can be dangerous especially since a significant portion of the leftist elite feigns membership in minority groups, e.g. Elizabeth Warren, Bernie Sanders, and that its aspiring presidential candidates, Barack Obama and Kamala Harris, did not come out of the African American community, even when they did, like Cory Booker, it was after a period of code-switching in elite circles, followed by a reversion and an attempt to then reidentify as black.
Whatever one’s feelings about Kamala are, there’s little question that identifying as black was a decision for her and, unlike Obama, not a permanent one, but a situational one. When it’s convenient, she’s black, when it’s convenient she’s Indian or even Asian, and when convenient she’s something more ambiguous.
It’s part of a pattern in which Kamala routinely disavows her own views, quotes, policies and past to be whatever empty vessel people want to see her as. Obama was guilty of that at times, but at least you could understand where his position was at any given time, with Kamala not even that is really true anymore.
Poetcomic1 says
The AVERAGE ‘African-American is 30% white.and those with percentages as high as 60-70% are common among the lighter skinned.. Maybe they should pay themselves reparations.
Greg says
Is the black half of the Kenyan owed reparations from his white half? That’s a metaphysical question akin to “how many pins can dance on the head of an angel?”
STJOHNOFGRAFTON says
I am one of those fortunate people on God’s earth who is both colour blind and a xenophile. For me it’s about how people behave. Those unfortunates who base their lives on what colour or race someone is are calling God a liar for what He said in Genesis 1:26. Little wonder that their lives are fraught with the consequences of their wicked notions of who they are.
Beto says
Color blindness is so old-school
NAVY ET1 says
Trump takes a lot of flak (from people who don’t understand him) for being crass with his comments. What often sounds as if it’s off the cuff usually isn’t, as was the case today when asked about Kamala.
“I didn’t know she was Black until a number of years ago when she happened to turn Black, and now she wants to be known as Black.”
The crowd roared because they understood completely. Democrats make for the perfect politicians because, without a moral compass, they’re free to say ANYTHING to maintain political power without that pesky conscious getting in the way.
🇺🇲 TRUMP ’24 🇺🇲
Jan VI says
I know about Elizabeth Warren, but how did Bernie Sanders “feign membership in minority groups”?
————————————————–
I don’t care much about Kamala’s ethnicity. It must be a bit confusing for her!
I do care about her character.
cat says
Hopefully your question is sincere. He is of descent that is genetically Jewish as I understand it. He opposes all policies views and perspectives that would benefit, help, respect, or secure Jewish people in the USA and Israel. But he may use his background (not to mention his Brooklyn accent) to “shmooze” when convenient to do so
Martina Vaslovik says
The Left loves to reduce everything to race as it’s a means of polarizing society against itself, so they are quite willing to fake their race to that end. All of the woke social justice issues are about the same thing, creating as much societal chaos and division as possible pursuant to a Marxist revolution in America and the west in general. Woke is Maoism with American characteristics. Communism thrives in chaos.
internalexile says
VERY well, and economically, stated. Sounds like you may have been there (or relatives, perhaps?)
Mike says
Race, sex, sexuality, being gender fluid, transgender, non binary or whatever the current phrase of the day is (who can keep up) is not a talent or qualification for any job or political office.
This is so clear and obvious I can’t believe I have to write this or say it out loud.
Algorithmic Analyst says
She would probably be considered an outcaste by orthodox Hinduism.